Skip to main content

The Bad Economics of an Overspending Lifestyle

DebtWave

Back in high school, I could remember how I often overspent during my teenage years. It wasn't "easy" to have thrifty parents but it was worth it. College came in and I remembered how I had to deal with different types of people at the University of San Carlos-Main Campus (USC-Main). It could be seen that various people of various classes were spotted. There were rich people who valued money, rich people who no longer became rich because of their bad money habits, poor people who manage money well and are no longer poor but not necessarily rich, and poor people who don't value money as much as the overspending rich. Spending is part of economics. However, too much spending is basically too much of a good thing and becomes junk. Junk food contains excessive salt and sugar--both of which are beneficial but end up damaging the body in excess. That's why it's called junk food.

I think about the typical Pinoy spending habits and what went wrong. I confess that there are some Tsinoys who are also overspenders. I was thinking about how college changed my perception of money. My parents gave me a limited allowance, didn't give me everything I want, and I must confess I only got money for necessities. Eventually, I had to learn to manage the money I had from the family business. Then I remembered some things about the attitude towards money. Some of older schoolmates should've been my seniors. Instead, it was amazing how I got my status promotion while others who were older than me--were now beneath me in terms of standing. Some of them even said something like that their parents didn't care even if it took many years to get that degree. What was even more surprising is that they weren't rich at all! Some even go as far as to keep hating the rich only because they're rich. 

Analyzing why Filipinos tend to overspend 

I was thinking about how, as a Filipino-Chinese, that overspending is a very common thing. So far, there are five reasons that you might want to observe. They're evaluated as follows:
  1. The hot pandesal syndrome (aka bandwagon effect)
  2. Possibly, cultural DNA (but again, culture isn't static)
  3. The social status trap
  4. The "Global Citizen" mentality (all the while having a wrong perception of foreign direct investments or FDI)
  5. Spending based on emotions
Somehow, I could agree with these ones. I could talk about how these things happen one way or another. These tend to be linked together one way or another. I think emotional spending is what summarizes the first four points. It could also be very true which can be summarized by this statement of Amy Fontanille, a personal finance expert:
"Emotional spending occurs when you buy something you don’t need and, in some cases, don’t even really want, as a result of feeling stressed out, bored, under-appreciated, incompetent, unhappy, or any number of other emotions."

This would be the problem of spending based on feelings over facts and figures. It would be pretty much apparent in the following situations that I've observed:

  1. It's very often the bandwagon effect is based on feelings than facts. It's like if you don't have this--you must be very poor. That perception of wealth based on possessions rather than the amount of money in the bank is really often shown. For example, you must have the latest video game console or be left out. However, a video game console is a want and not a need. Not having the latest video game console doesn't mean you're poor--it might mean the parents are need-focused. Some rich children don't get everything they want either.
  2. The feeling of "cultural DNA" maybe another. It seems that it's almost impossible to separate being a spendthrift from being a Filipino. It really shouldn't be associated with such. What can be observed is celebrating beyond one's means. It's not wrong to celebrate but celebrating lavishly when one has little to no money is. Just think about how Christmas and New Year in the Philippines (which got canceled by Odette in some areas) tend to be celebrated with lots of debt. January comes and the Five-Six Lenders may be asking for their money back.
  3. The social status trap is, as said, thinking one is wealthy based on what one has rather than how much money you have. It's something to be belittled for driving a Toyota while using a Samsung while the other is driving a BMW and having an iPhone. However, the person driving a Toyota while using a Samsung may have more money. The other person with a BMW and an iPhone might be broke as a joke. The person may be BWM (broke without money) and has no ipon (Tagalog for savings) which the person may be chased by bad creditors. Having status symbols may be another reason why someone became poor. It's not inherently wrong to have them but most of them are just overrated. It's best to stick to what works than status symbols that may end up doing a disservice to the users.
  4. The "global citizen" status is another. It's really something when some overseas Filipino workers (OFW) have their families ask this and that. It's not easy working abroad. However, you may have friends and extended family members asking for this and that such as a brand new iPhone or the latest video game console. This also goes back to the social status trap again. 

The end results of overspending can be rather vicious

Overspending, whether we want to admit it or not, has bad end results I was thinking about the situation based on how COVID-19 hit then Odette. Before that, I still think about how Christmas and New Year can be the worst times in the Philippines. The Christmas season becomes a stressful season to do groceries. I would want to think that people wait for their bonuses because of the tendency to (1) not handle money well for the rest of the year, and (2) the need for lavish celebrations. Not handling money means one may end up having to wait for the Christmas bonus and the 13th-month pay. When the money arrives--there's the tendency to misuse it too. 

The recent COVID-19 crisis (hopefully, it'll end soon) and Typhoon Odette made me think about stuff. I was thinking what if I lived lavishly like a king? What if I decided to buy expensive apparel that I know would just wear itself out like my non-branded apparel? What if I decided to keep getting luxury items when I can settle for affordable quality items? Those were questions I asked myself when Odette hit and there was COVID-19. Having contingency planning was helpful. Expenses were piling up but they could be paid. Materials used to disinfect to prevent severe COVID-19 were there. 

Meanwhile, others choose to blame the rich instead of their lifestyle that doesn't value money. It's like how somebody said that her parents didn't care how long it took her to finish college. Other poor people have been working to make sure they finish college, get a good job, and save up their money. It can also be ironic how some refuse to get insurance while they have no problem going gambling and getting drunk. Where's the Return On Investment (ROI) in drinking and gambling? It will only result in accumulated losses because there's nothing to gain in engaging in such activities. The money runs out resulting in them not having money when they truly need it.

This, in turn, makes people who overspend want easy money. The consequences that I've observed are as follows:
  1. They would want to join game shows rather than get a proper job. I was wondering if somebody's obsession with Kapamilya Deal or No Deal back then was a result of wanting easy money?
  2. It would be easy to fall for investment scams. Scammers just love to fool people who are financially illiterate or desire easy money. Scams like give us your money with "fast returns" is one. I remembered spamming messages on my smartphone that offered to pay me PHP 8,000.00 a day. Is there such a company that can pay me like that in the Philippines? Yet, some end up buying it, and the scammers use them. It's no wonder why some working-class people fell for it even if their bosses warn them against it. As said, if it's too good to be true then reject that investment!
  3. Even worse some can be easily recruited by criminal organizations. 11 years ago, I remembered the incident regarding three drug mules in China. I can't be sure of the motives why they joined but I can just assume that it's all about the desire for easy money. There's really easy money with drugs but like any easy returns--the risk can be much higher. Poverty is a very good breeding ground for criminality, right? Some people join crime organizations out of poverty though that's not an excuse to do so. Both the rich crime lord and the lower-class thugs should face the law.
It's really time to rethink--overspending isn't economics. It ignores economics. It really lives like as if money grows on trees or that it rains gold coins. Those are all scientific impossibilities and can't account for the overspending lifestyle. 

References

"5 Reasons Why Pinoys Overspend" by Faith Dayrit

"China executes three Filipinos for drugs smuggling"
Labels:

Popular posts from this blog

Davide vs. Mahathir: Which Lolo Should Filipinos Take Economic Advice From?

The real issue isn't that something is old or new. Instead, if something old or new still works, or doesn't work! Many modern laws are built on some ancient principles, while adjusting to the current times!  The Constitution of Japan is actually older than the 1987 Constitution of the Philippines. However, it's more effective for the reasons that (1) their constitution is silent when it comes to regulating economic activities (ex., protectionist measures), and (2) it's a parliamentary system. Honestly, it's a pretty straightforward constitution compared to ours! As Mahatir Mohamad turned 100 today, I would like to raise up Atty. Hilario G. Davide Jr. once again. The problem isn't Davide's age but his unwillingness to embrace change when needed (read here ). This time, it's time to bring up a contrast between wise old people and unwise old people. A young person can be right where the old person is wrong. A young person can be wiser because he or she lea...
Read more

Overspending as a Narcotic of the Filipino Masses

Harvard Health Publishing It's almost time for the New Year, right? However, there's the problem that so many Filipinos just refuse to do any financial New Year's resolutions . It's a continued series of broken New Year's resolutions year after year , such as not doing anything about one's financial and economic literacy . Then again, can Filipinos learn financial literacy when the school environment is  too theoretical ? As I observe the same cycle in the Philippines, from January to December, it has always been a financial mess for many Filipinos. The problem starts with mishandling money, such as how paychecks are often handled by people .  There's always some joy in spending, whether we want to admit it or not We can't deny that if we bought what we want (especially with one's own money), there's some feeling of satisfaction . For example, a person who stops begging from their parents and starts buying what they want, with  their money , can ...
Read more

Don't Complain About the PHP 500.00 Noche Buena Remark While Supporting the Filipino First Policy

It's that stupid  when I read the remarks of DTI secretary Cristina Roque made a really tactless remark . Sure, the remark had people angry because, in reality, the whole noche buena at PHP 500.00 for a family of four will not match, given these ingredients: ham, P170 to P945; fruit cocktail, P61.76 to P94.41; all-purpose cream, P36.00 to P72; “nata de coco,” P52.50 to P62.50; “kaong,” P76.50 to P84; “queso de bola,” P210 to P470; cheese, P16.50 to P310; and mayonnaise, P20.40 to P245.85. /dda As I read through the list above, I'm reminded of how much I don't like December because it's the season of abounding toxic positivity . The song "It's the Most Wonderful Time of the Year" is in full blast, even after Andy Williams died of old age in 2012 . I tend to drive the road and when traffic hits, I always think about the problem of last-minute Christmas shopping , and scream it, "Isn't it any wonder why the Philippines doesn't improve?" It...
Read more

External Validations, like Masters and Doctorate, Mean NOTHING with a LOUSY Education System

I have the tendency to use my MBA as a license to avoid criticism. It's a real problem that some people use their credentials and/or academic achievements to try and win an argument. One incident I wrote about was Rep. Raoul Abellar Manuel flexing his "smarts" by using his cum laude degree to win the argument . It was all about how I would often say, "You're the moron because I have the MBA and you don't." There are times I felt like taking an MBA would make up for my "moral shortcomings" during high school when I was barely passing (and the passing rate was 80% , which is rather high), that I wasn't having honors, and that there was this saying, " Thou grades shalt determine thy future! " That, of course, has led to the reality where cheating is prevalent .  I wanted to make a review. I took my MBA in 2011 and graduated in 2014. I always felt that the MBA program was what I needed to become "invincible". It was also at ...
Read more

Warren Buffett's Principles NOT Taught in Business School?

I'm a graduate of a business school. I felt ashamed (to a certain extent) that I wasn't accepted into the Bachelor of Science in Information Technology (BSIT) course. I decided to pursue business school instead as planned after my first year in my Associate in Computer Science (ACS) course. I decided to take a master's degree to impress others or to convince them I'm not a fool. Later on, while taking my Masters in Business Administration (MBA) degree--I fell into a scam by a family friend and later didn't even know what Cash 2 Go in the Metrobank credit card was. After a heated argument with someone questioning my course, I was finally told the hard truth I needed to hear, "That proves the Filipino education system really sucks !" I finally had my MBA. Later, I discovered a lot of stuff that I was never taught . One of them was actually the best investment to put into even in the finance classes! Sure, finance classes are needed but shouldn't we teach...
Read more