Skip to main content

The Ghost of the Quadriga-CX Crypto-Scam

Newsweek

I was looking for yet another exciting topic to write about. It turns out that I might as well deal with yet another reason why I'm not entering into the creepy world of cryptocurrency. Now, a new documentary on Netflix known as Trust No One: Hunt for the Crypto King features yet another scam. You may have heard of the crypto-queen from Bulgaria, Ruja Ignatova, who's currently in hiding. Right now, Ignatova is just missing. In the case of the Crypto-King, Gerald Cotten, it was reported that he died last December 9, 2018. However, some people assume that he might have faked his death in India, which for some, didn't make sense. Even his widow had testified that she was with him when he died. Though, events like the funeral where the coffin wasn't opened for public viewing or other stuff may suggest that he faked his death. The documentary did reveal how a scammer faked suicide and later turned himself in. 

Why did people enter into deals with Quadriga-CX?


A Chinese-Canadian guy named Tong Zou, a victim of the scam appeared in the said documentary. I think it's essential that if you're hit by a fraud--warn others of this person. I remembered being victimized by a scam by a family friend. It was a lot of money which was never recovered. I've known others who lost millions and never recovered. Tong Zou had claimed he foolishly placed his life savings into the transaction hoping it'd grow big. Some people made that mistake with stocks only to find out that stocks don't easily grow either. Stock markets aren't a get-rich-quick scheme. However, Quadriga's cryptocurrency was pretty much it. As Tong said, "I was greedy." He shared his story so it doesn't happen to other people. His losing CSD 500,000.00 is no joke. This is a very brave move especially if you've been hit. 

If there was any reason why I nearly entered a pyramid scheme and got scammed by bad credit by a family friend--I dare to say it was greed. People are into the crypto-craze because of how fast it skyrocketed compared to stocks. Monitoring the stock market daily can be a chore. Let's say that you bought some Jollibee stocks when prices were low due to factors like low demand and surplus. The prices of Jollibee stocks don't easily go up or go down. Instead, stocks can have a steady decline or steady increase except in cases like a crash caused by a political or economic outlook. In this case, the price of the cryptocurrency by Quadriga-X started to skyrocket. People bought them in hopes of becoming wealthy fast. But like nay get-rich-quick scheme--the money that's easily gained is easily gone. Nobody got rich with stocks overnight. Nobody got rich with managed funds overnight either. In fact, any good fund manager will say, "Let's just wait for an increase." Any good self-trader of stocks will know when to hold and when to sell.

Shady details regarding Cotten's and his company Quadriga-CX

Some details regarding Mr. Cotten would rather be frightening according to the Independent which really was also mentioned in the same documentary:
As detailed in recent documentaries like the CBC’s Dead Man’s Switch: a crypto mystery (2021) and Netflix’s Trust No One: The Hunt for the Crypto King (2022), Cotten had been defrauding investors and lying to his family for years, in what the Ontario Securities Commission would eventually declare a Ponzi scheme.

Tong Zou, 33, lost his life savings on Quadriga, including a $200,000 gift from his parents, as he describes in the Netflix film.

"I want to share my story so it doesn’t happen to other people," he told Sky News in March.

In addition to siphoning off nearly $20m in funds for personal use, Cotten also lost more than $90m of Quadriga customers’ cash making fraudulent trades on and off the exchange, sometimes using accounts with Star Wars-inspired spoof screen names like “Aretwo Deetwo” and “Seethree Peaohh.”

The company didn’t even have an official bank account, processing payments through third parties or Cotten’s own laptop. The Cottens’ home was filled with piles and piles of loose cash, which Gerry claimed was a consequence of supposedly discriminatory banks who didn’t yet understand crypto and refused to work with them. It would also be revealed that the businessman had started scamming people online at age 15, and had ties to Midas Gold, a business linked to a Costa Rican money laundering operation.

Perhaps the central argument for the ascendancy of cryptocurrency is its supposed transparency: every transaction made with bitcoin is logged on a public ledger called the blockchain, though the identity of the trader isn’t always clear. Quadriga tested these principles to the fullest.

Regulators were able to recover about $27m of customer funds, and Robertson turned over almost all of her possessions in a bankruptcy settlement, including $12m in assets and the couple’s extravagant possessions, but nearly $200m remains missing or inaccessible. 

The details given would tell you that Quadriga-CX couldn't be trusted. If the company has no official bank account then shouldn't that be a red flag that something is wrong? Though, remember that the Legacy Group of Companies was once registered with the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC). The very idea of being full of loose cash at Cohen's home already suggests something--it might be very possible that the money was meant for underground purposes. The money at home may have been sent for the Costa Rican money laundering operation. The documentary even showed how Cotten and his wife had a luxurious lifestyle as well. It seems that the operation to make a foundation in India may have been another legal front for monkey businesses.

Some of these details from his widow (if ever he's really dead) also reveal this from The Independent:

She began recalling whole conversations with Gerry that seemed entirely fabricated in retrospect. In one exchange, Cotten had been going on and on about the greedy Canadian government taking millions via taxes. Jennifer eventually learned that Cotten hadn’t been paying taxes at all.

In short, if the company isn't a registered taxpayer then why even bother? Zou in the same documentary even mentioned he wanted to avoid the two percent commission from the banks so he traded with Quadriga-CX.  Apparently, Cotten's scheme was so he could get rich without paying taxes. I'm not saying overtaxing can be a good thing. However, not paying taxes isn't a good thing either. Any company that's not paying taxes can't be trusted either. Taxes are used to finance government spending. Cotten accused the Canadian government of being greedy while he was indeed greedy himself. That would probably help explain why he preferred to use cryptocurrency in all his trading--it's because there's more anonymity and the identity isn't always clear.

It's one thing if people use anonymous names online for privacy reasons. Gaming communities just want to use names to look cool. Others prefer to use anonymous names while operating sites maybe as a trading name or just a preferred name. Many times, other writers also used pen names such as how Jose Rizal's real name was José Protasio Rizal Mercado y Alonso Realonda and he used the names Laong Laan, Dimasalang, and Plaridel. Eric Arthur Blair used the pen name George Orwell to publish his famous novel Animal Farm. Many times, pen names (which may come off as a trading name) are registered. Celebrities tend to use screen names like how Sharon Garcia Magdayao is known as Vina Morales. However, Gerry most likely didn't register any of his pen names when he was trading. Why would he? I doubt any of his pen names were registered as trade names! It's one thing to write with a pen name as a hobby. It's another thing to use a pen name in accepting payments using cryptocurrency. Besides, none of those screen names may have copyrights to make them even valid for business purposes. 

I think it would be one thing if I were trading with a certain "George Orwell Animal Farm" if this screen name is actually a company. This fictional company I created for fictitious purposes was registered in a bank as a company account. Another is how Severino Reyes created the fictional character Lola Basyang under a trademark. So, any sales of the book with the name "Lola Basyang" are still registered with the government for the purpose of taxation. It doesn't seem to be the case with what Cotten did with his Star Wars-inspired screen names. I could buy a book written under a pen name. However, I can't do trading under anyone who's purely anonymous. Sure, there's a privacy policy for trading but certain details are made public for a purpose. It's like how AXA or the Philippine Stock Exchange have their fund managers and brokers under their real names. So, while a person can still earn money under a registered pen name--what Cotten did was cheating nonetheless. I doubt that they were professional aliases too. 

Another warning is to be careful of first impressions

For one, Cotten seemed to be that very friendly guy. In fact, people were carried off by his charming charisma as this all-around nice guy. Sometimes the person you think is a flirt may not be a flirt. Sometimes, the person you wouldn't think is a cheat is a cheat. He had a very pleasant image and looked very professional. However, not everyone who looks nice can be trusted. I'm not saying that we should get rid of power dressing in businesses. Dressing up in good attire can help attract customers. The problem is that this guy misused his professional image according to the documentary. 

I was reminded of how some pyramid investors are rather very pleasant. There's such a thing as a very smooth talker. A smooth talker is someone who says very flattering things and may be confident that they can convince people. However, such a person isn't automatically honest. Sure, we have honest people who have confidence in what they say. There are swindlers who have a very good way of talking so they can deceive someone into giving in. It's pretty much like how I was talked into selling in credit to someone because she was a very smooth talker. It might be a lesson to some that if a person flatters you too much--be very careful! The person may be a sweet talker which means using insincere praise to persuade something to do something. It's possible to be a smooth talker but not use dishonesty. One could confidently talk about a functioning product as a smooth talker. Meanwhile, to sweet talk is to be dishonest in one's trade. A sweet talker would convince you to enter a too-good-to-be-true deal one way or another.

I think the case of Cotten was that he was a sweet-talker. How can you expect him not to owe at least 27,000 (recorded) cases of swindles? It took some time to know that he was actually a bad trader. The documentary compared what he did to gambling. I guess he sweet-talked people into investing with him so he could use it for his monkey business. Though their current website now redirects to another cryptocurrency service called CryptoQuadriga which claims to be not affiliated with QuadrigaCX Bitcoin Trading Exchange. I visited the site but as said--I want to avoid cryptocurrency because of its dangers from what I heard. It might make fast money for some but it seems to always operate at robbing X to pay Y like a Ponzi scheme.

It was interesting that someone who's currently known as QCXINT was there to reveal the details. Apparently, he chose to remain anonymous for privacy reasons. The person was also a victim and may have been harassed for all we know. A lot of details ended up creating the documentary that actually convinced me more as to why I'm not going into the cryptocurrency craze and neither should you. 

References

Documentaries

"Trust No One: The Hunt for the Crypto King", Directed by Luke Seewell, Distributed by Netflix 

Websites

"After losing $163 million in cryptocurrency, investors call to exhume Quadriga CEO’s body"

"'Bitcoin widow' reveals how she fell victim to her own husband's $215m scam after his mysterious death" by John Marcus (April 15, 2022)

Labels

Labels:

Popular posts from this blog

Keep Calm and Continue Investing in Stocks, Despite the Current Situation This 2025

FQ Mom It's no secret that   U.S. President Donald J. Trump's tariffs may backfire . Should I even be surprised at the results that the global stock market are going low? It's something to think about why I didn't get invested in stocks ASAP. It's because I don't have a calm personality. However, I realized that the key in stock market investing is, "Keep calm and invest long term." Nobody should ever think of investing in stocks hoping to get rich quick fast!  The   FQ Mom   provides useful advice that I should do, as I check my equity funds at an almost daily basis: 1. Understand the stock market. It is the avenue where we can all participate in the ownership of the listed companies. This facility that allows us to buy and sell stocks with ease anytime during trading hours also goes with a “price.” We see the stock prices go up and down like crazy every second, something that does not happen in other asset classes. To borrow from Benjamin Graham in h...
Read more

Why I Support Taiwanese Politician Yeh Yi Jin's Proposal for Taiwan to Drop Zhuyin Entirely (in Favor of Pinyin)

Taiwan News It may be news from 2018 (meaning, five years ago) but as a person who sees the importance of Mandarin in the international market, I still want to react. Not surprisingly, Yeh Yi Jin lost the Tainan mayoral bid because of her controversial statement to abolish Zhuyin from Taiwan altogether . She may have lost the race but I'm still supporting her for this. It's not because I kept failing hard in Zhuyin back in my days. It's because I feel that as time goes on, some things need to be dropped like asking students to submit their reports written via typewriter or asking documents to be faxed when email (and modern standard mail) are more reliable. Like I argued with an investment before, I said, "You can't fax a book. Can I just mail it?" The bank kept arguing it had to be faxed. Unfortunately stubborn boomers, stubborn boomers, everywhere, right? From The Free China Post , this is what's said about Yeh's argument: Yeh argues that using zhuyi...
Read more

The Filipino First Policy Caused the Philippines to Succeed!

High School Philippine History Movement Yes, you read it right! I found a hidden gem that I should've read years ago! It's the book Nationalist Economics by the late Alejandro Lichauco, who is part of the magnificent IBON Foundation. It's a shame I refused to read it. I should've read Lichauco's book instead of the late Lee Kuan Yew's book From Third World to First . What a shame that I didn't look into the details that LKY was a dictator, that Flor Contemplacion was indeed innocent, and that Singapore is a state comparable to Nazi Germany. As I bought my copy of Nationalist Economics from the Trust Me Bro School of Economics--I'm now convinced that the Filipino First Policy caused us to succeed! LKY ruled Singapore for 31 years, meaning it's a frightening thing indeed! Six years is the magic number ot establish a benevolent rule!  Who should we all listen to? Should we listen to foreigners or should we listen to our fellow Filipino? We must think st...
Read more

The Lesson of "Bad Genius" is More Than Just "Cheating Never Pays Off"

Sometimes, much truth can be told in fiction, right? Talk about how the great Jose Rizal revealed much truth in his fictional novels Noli Me Tangere and El Filibusterismo . The digital age today would create more entertaining media. I may encourage book reading over movie watching. However, some movies may do more than entertain. They can also address a real issue. It was said that a cheating scandal in China inspired the producers Jira Maligool and Vanridee Pongsittisak to create the film  Bad Genius . Right now, there's even a TV series presumably because a movie can't always deliver the message one wants. How does the whole thing go? I was inspired to watch this film because of comments from a Facebook friend's post. The post also talked about how students cheat because the system cares more about grades than learning.  As the world becomes more global, exposure to Thai cinema is definitely not surprising. Sure, one can talk about the South Korean wave or the increasin...
Read more

When the Education Cares TOO MUCH About Grades, Schools Produce Idiots Instead of Intellectuals

During the pandemic, I was left in limbo thinking about my poor performance under K+10. It was something to think about that a classmate of mine who was both a summa cum laude and an honor student, ended up posting on his wall, "Students cheat because the education system cares more about grades instead of learning." The class salutatorian of our batch even commented about the good old days. I always had that feeling of insecurity and envy towards people better than me. But as Warren Edward Buffet would say, "Don't hate successful people. Learn from them instead." One of them is currently a teacher and the other is in Canada. I thought about my insecurities especially when I used to believe I was descended from a fine scholar and my family was a family of scholars.  I remembered the time I was taking MBA and got conned. I was asked, "Is that what MBA taught you?" I got touchy and ended up admitting, eventually, that I was only taking MBA for the presti...
Read more

Why I Believe 100% Shares Ownership of Public Utilities Will Help Benefit Filipino Businessmen

Accru Melbourne Typhoon Odette certainly blew another serious blow in the Philippines, didn't it? I could remember the Typhoon Ruping when I was only in Kinder 2. Memories in kindergarten may fade over time but a few don't--such as how some people may mention that they failed kinder for sleeping in classes. The passage of the bill that allows 100% ownership of shares in public utilities has been condemned by certain Filipino organizations such as the League of Filipino Students, Kabataan Partylist, and Bayan Muna. The same old cry of "imperialism" is funny since these groups are using American made social media (such as Facebook and Twitter), they may be ordering meals from Grab which is from Singapore , they are using gadgets made from other countries (such as iPhones which were most likely assembled in China), and other stuff which were obviously not Filipino in origin. A heavy lesson from Odette and other previous disasters The reason why Odette restoration couldn...
Read more

I Believe Social Media Gossip is Why Some Enter into Cryptocurrency

It would be interesting to think about how people got into cryptocurrencies like Bitcoin. I watched the documentary Trust No One: The Hunt for the Crypto King on Netflix, (read the review here ). The documentary really showed this one fact--social media gossipers make poor financial advisors (read here ). The trend to join stuff like the Quadriga-CX scam or how Ruja Ignatova (who's still missing and probably still alive) got a huge following.  BBC News also shows how Ignatova's Bitcoin following was developed by social media gossip : Why have so many people continued to believe in OneCoin, despite all the evidence?  Investors often told us that what drew them in initially was the fear that they would miss out on the next big thing. They'd read, with envy, the stories of people striking gold with Bitcoin and thought OneCoin was a second chance. Many were struck by the personality and persuasiveness of the "visionary" Dr Ruja. Investors might not have understood the...
Read more

Learning from the Indian Economic Legacy of Third World to First

CNN Today is Indian Independence Day. It's very easy to look down at India that's until you realize that it went from an impoverished former British colony to an emerging country. It's 75 years of India's independence from Great Britain. I feel it's time to write another economics-related post for this blog. Before that, you may want to read about Deng Xiaoping's real great leap forward (read here ). Though, if you don't mind then you can start reading this post which I will talk about in this post. CNN has Rhea Mogul shares this insight on India's economic growth : Rise of an economic power   Following independence, India was in chaos. Reeling from a bloody partition that killed between 500,000 and 2 million people, and uprooted an estimated 15 million more, it was synonymous with poverty .   Average life expectancy in the years after the British left was just 37 for men and 36 for women, and only 12% of Indians were literate. The country's GDP was ...
Read more

Foreign Investors Only Get Rich Based on Net Income AFTER Taxes

Malaya Business Insight Above is an artwork by the late Neil Doloricon which was shared on Malaya Business Insight page. I'm amazed by this ignorance can easily be traced to what the late Lee Kuan Yew said in his book From Third World to First . I'm almost finished reading the book and I might reread certain portions of it. Doloricon's artwork is very misleading  for this reason. It's pretty much a lack of understanding of profits in accounting and finances. Both accounting and finance would deal with how much money is left after expenses. Foreign investors are no different in that regard--they operate based on profits. The picture says that the foreign investors get rich leaving the Philippines with nothing. However, that's a very misleading picture for this reason--that is if you think your sales for the day are your profits for the day. We must understand the concept of revenues vs. income . I guess the fools who say that only foreign investors will get rich ar...
Read more

Bongbong's Story of the Little Piaya Store That Could

It's been some time since I did a food review, right? As of right now, I feel like I've been burdened not taking Hotel & Restaurant Management and chose Business Administration instead. Both departments today are under the School of Business and Economics (SBE) at the University of San Carlos (USC).  Having been a fan of almost everything that they can offer to customers--I decided to do some research. I'm not surprised that its owner, Reynaldo B. Villan Sr. aka Bongbong. The timeline from their very own website shares the humble beginnings of Bongbong or Villan Sr. Right now, you can check all their branches here . The humble beginnings of Villan Sr. (I'll use this one instead of Bongbong to avoid confusion with Philippine President, Ferdinand R. Marcos Jr. who goes by that nickname) aren't surprising. I've read how Jollibee was the little bee that could. Tony Tancaktiong wasn't born wealthy and had to face the challenge of foreign food companies. Vill...
Read more