Skip to main content

Anti-Capitalists Have No Choice Because Capitalists Hold the Means of Production?


I don't know if I should be laughing or cringing at what I deem to be stupidity. Some will say that methods of production aren't linked to either capitalism or socialism. The video above is from Jacobin's contributor Rob Larson. It's no surprise that Jacobin is also the source material for pages that support protectionist policies for the Philippines. I watched it and I find it hilarious to a certain extent. According to anti-capitalists, they have no choice but to use capitalist products because the evil capitalists own the methods of production. Larson even goes as far as to say capitalism didn't invent the iPhone. It's true that the Internet was originally a military invention but guess who caused technologies created by the government to go further? It's all about private enterprises regulated by the government. We got all sorts of new technology today because of the collaboration of private enterprises and the government. 

What is capitalism?

First, let's define capitalism and how it works. Capitalism is simply defined by Investopedia as:
...an economic system in which private individuals or businesses own capital goods. The production of goods and services is based on supply and demand in the general market—known as a market economy—rather than through central planning—known as a planned economy or command economy.

Basically, capitalism can be bad if one engages in anarcho-capitalism or capitalism without government regulation. It would be insane to have businesses competing with each other without rules to govern them. Democracy isn't an absence of rules either--that would be anarchy. Rules are applied such as businesses will have to pay taxes, treat workers properly, provide worker benefits (which are paid through government offices), the fair competition act, laws governing both lessors and tenants, and the like are mandated to control the business atmosphere. I could kick out a bad tenant because the government has given me that power. Meanwhile, I can't kick a tenant out of spite because the government doesn't allow it. These rules balance the business atmosphere. This is basically the government's regulated capitalism. Some may call it a mixed economy where government and private enterprises are at work.  

The argument of the anti-capitalist is to abolish private property or the right to own property. This is pretty much part of Karl Marx's 10 Planks of Communism--the abolition of private property. This was the very system that was done by infamous dead tyrants such as Pol Pot (whose reign was rather cut short), Mao Zedong, and Kim Il Sung (founder of the Kim Dynasty). Mao tried to prove Communism's superiority during the Great Leap Forward--something history has recorded to be rather unfavorable one way or another. Mao's insane scheme confiscated private property (which began with the landlords) and transferred them as his private property. Mao set up unrealistic quotas and gave poor materials, to begin with--that's why the Great Leap Forward was a failure.  Today, North Korea stands as a testament to why anti-capitalism doesn't work--except for the Kim Dynasty.

If anti-capitalists want to be consistent--they should really reject anything produced out of exploitation. Some people defected from North Korea to South Korea so they can use resources freely without using the government's provisions for long. They should start manufacturing everything themselves first. It's because if they can manufacture better products themselves then they can truly have the right to overthrow capitalism. If not, they really are just all talk and no walk. 

How capitalist production with reasonable restrictions work

In contrast, capitalism has created better methods of production through competition. Of course, this requires the government to regulate it such as setting registrations, patents, trademarks, fair competition act, consumer protection, and other reasonable restrictions. A business gets registered and it becomes a legal entity. What happens is that every private enterprise registered becomes a taxpayer. The protection isn't free either since taxes are required. There are various government agencies that handle private problems such as corrupt revenue officers, bad employees, abusive employers, corrupt inspectors, and the like. The government also sets rules that will protect customers and employees from being exploited by dirty businesses. Businesses that don't follow these rules can face appropriate penalties such as huge fines, business closure, and/or even jail time. Meanwhile, those who follow government rules can still continue to play in the business competition.

How did competition between private enterprises improve production? The government made a set of rules. Such rules would prevent private enterprises from stealing intellectual property from each other. Such rules would require businesses to pay taxes and treat their workers right. If you want to be on top--you need to follow the rules meant to protect the business environment. Since there are rules for the protection of intellectual property rights--businesses will have to be as creative as possible. It's pretty much like how food industries will have to make sure their dishes taste good without stealing someone's secret formula. The result of competition while having an intellectual property rights law will make unique products. It's like how one milk tea store differs from another. It's like how one smartphone differs from another. Many products are different from one another because the government sets an intellectual property law while allowing private enterprises to fill the supply/demand gap. That means foreign direct investors (FDIs) can't steal intellectual property rights from Filipino investors or mistreat Filipino workers. It's because once registered as a business competitor--you need to follow the rules. 

Besides, the government ends up benefiting from the private enterprises too. A good example is how some private enterprises' venues were used during the COVID-19 vaccination. Some malls today even become extensions for government offices. I remembered going to Robinsons' Galleria to get my Social Security ID. I remembered going to the University of Cebu-Downtown to get my first two COVID-19 shots. Government offices end up getting filled with capitalist devices. Governments end up hiring the services of private construction firms to build public works and highways. Government offices may end up catering from a restaurant for their Christmas parties. If the national government seized all production then government offices will eventually be forced to use substandard products. Government websites would probably hang up a lot more if there were no private servers. It's a balance between government and private enterprise that makes good governance. 

What we need is a balance between private ownership and government. A government that supports capitalism is a good government. Though, one can argue that China and Vietnam have a free market (in which economic exchange is free from coercive government influence) while they remain as Communist countries. However, both Communist countries still have a certain degree of private enterprises even when ownership of land is hardly allowed. What we need is a government that has reasonable regulations for capitalism. Government should be regulating capitalism instead of overly restricting it. The lesson can be learned from the rise of power in countries like Taiwan, Singapore, and South Korea. 

References

"Capital" by Marshall Hargrave, reviewed by Bryan Barnier, fact-checked by Yarilet Perez (Updated: April 3, 2022)

"Capitalism" by The Investopedia Team, reviewed by Marguerita Cheng, fact-checked by Pete Rathburn

"The "10 Planks" of the Communist Manifesto"

"What Was the Great Leap Forward?" Written by The Investopedia Team, Reviewed by Michael J. Byle (Updated: September 22, 2021)

Popular posts from this blog

The Malaysian-Filipino Sweet Tooth Demographic

As a Filipino, I've observed the Filipino diet tends to lean on a sweet tooth. What causes this probable genetic disposition of the Filipino to crave sweets? That trait might be traced to one's ancestors. Newsweek also mentions it might be with the DNA . The Malaysians and the Filipinos have close genetics. The Britannica also cites this about Filipinos: The ethnically diverse people of the Philippines collectively are called Filipinos.  The ancestors of the vast majority of the population were of Malay descent and came from the Southeast Asian mainland as well as from what is now Indonesia . Contemporary Filipino society consists of nearly 100 culturally and linguistically distinct ethnic groups. Of these, the largest are the Tagalog of Luzon and the Cebuano of the Visayan Islands, each of which constitutes about one-fifth of the country’s total population. Other prominent groups include the Ilocano of northern Luzon and the Hiligaynon (Ilongo) of the Visayan islands of Panay...

Learning Mandarin Chinese Through Melons

Hanlin Language Center In pursuit of encouraging people ot learn Mandarin Chinese, here's a chart teaching the different types of melons in Chinese. Learning how to speak Chinese with these melons would be a productive exercise. Aside from using what was often called bon toi in the Chinese schools, it might be good to help people memorize these types of sentences, with the translation: Chinese: "å¤©ę°”ēƒ­ļ¼Œęƒ³åƒč„æē“œ." (TiānqƬ rĆØ, xiĒŽng chÄ« xÄ«guā.) Translation: "It's hot, I want to eat watermelon." Chinese: "ä½ ęƒ³å–å†¬ē“œčŒ¶å—?" (Nǐ xiĒŽng hē dōngguā chĆ” ma?) Translation: "Do you want to drink winter melon tea?" Chinese: "ęˆ‘č¦åšå—ē“œę“¾." (WĒ’ yĆ o zuò nĆ”nguā pĆ i.) Translation: "I'm going to cook pumpkin pie." Chinese: "ē”Øé»„ē“œåŽ»ēœ¼č¢‹." (Yòng huĆ”ngguā qù yĒŽndĆ i) Translation: "Use cucumber on your eye bags." Chinese: "č‹¦ē“œåÆ¹ä½ ēš„å„åŗ·ęœ‰ē›Š." (KĒ”guā duƬ nǐ de jiĆ nkāng yĒ’uyƬ) Translation: "Bitter gourd is good for your health." Chin...

A Consequence of Adobe's Subscription Model?!

As I look at this video, I don't regret not opening an Adobe account. I used Adobe Photoshop back in college--back when I could borrow someone's CD and install it on my computer. However, paying thousands of PHP  monthly  is ridiculous for a casual user! Why would I pay thousands of PHP just to produce artwork that I'm not even selling? Back then, I used Photoshop mostly to relax during semestral breaks in college. What happened to the good old days? As I listened to this video, I was disgusted at how Adobe could be a "Get Rich Quick Scheme" against its customers. Instead of selling Adobe Photoshop (or any service) outright (that's until the newer version arrives), they decide to use the subscription model. I could understand if Adobe offers a subscription model for intensive work that requires intensive power. Meanwhile, Adobe could offer a one-time purchase of any of its software for non-professional use. This reminds me why relying on past successes isn...

Keep Calm and Continue Investing in Stocks, Despite the Current Situation This 2025

FQ Mom It's no secret that   U.S. President Donald J. Trump's tariffs may backfire . Should I even be surprised at the results that the global stock market are going low? It's something to think about why I didn't get invested in stocks ASAP. It's because I don't have a calm personality. However, I realized that the key in stock market investing is, "Keep calm and invest long term." Nobody should ever think of investing in stocks hoping to get rich quick fast!  The   FQ Mom   provides useful advice that I should do, as I check my equity funds at an almost daily basis: 1. Understand the stock market. It is the avenue where we can all participate in the ownership of the listed companies. This facility that allows us to buy and sell stocks with ease anytime during trading hours also goes with a ā€œprice.ā€ We see the stock prices go up and down like crazy every second, something that does not happen in other asset classes. To borrow from Benjamin Graham in h...

The Lesson of "Bad Genius" is More Than Just "Cheating Never Pays Off"

Sometimes, much truth can be told in fiction, right? Talk about how the great Jose Rizal revealed much truth in his fictional novels Noli Me Tangere and El Filibusterismo . The digital age today would create more entertaining media. I may encourage book reading over movie watching. However, some movies may do more than entertain. They can also address a real issue. It was said that a cheating scandal in China inspired the producers Jira Maligool and Vanridee Pongsittisak to create the film  Bad Genius . Right now, there's even a TV series presumably because a movie can't always deliver the message one wants. How does the whole thing go? I was inspired to watch this film because of comments from a Facebook friend's post. The post also talked about how students cheat because the system cares more about grades than learning.  As the world becomes more global, exposure to Thai cinema is definitely not surprising. Sure, one can talk about the South Korean wave or the increasin...

Getting Nuts About Standard Chinese, By Learning About the Chinese Names of Nuts

Hanbridge Mandarin In pursuing the need to teach Mandarin Chinese, it's important to deviate from the old-fashioned Chinese language education (read here ). Instead, we need to get people interested in basic vocabulary. This would be a good exercise to learn from basic sentence making and conversations.  Here's an example of what's called bon toi back in my day. Let's think of learning Chinese through nuts. Question: ä½ ęƒ³č¦å·“č„æåšęžœć€ę øę”ƒć€ęä»čæ˜ę˜Æč…°ęžœ? (Nǐ xiĒŽng yĆ o bāxÄ« jiānguĒ’, hĆ©tĆ”o, xƬngrĆ©n hĆ”ishƬ yāoguĒ’) Translation: Do you want brazil nuts, walnuts, almonds, or cashews? Answer: ęˆ‘ęƒ³č¦ęä»ļ¼Œéžåøøę„Ÿč°¢. (WĒ’ xiĒŽng yĆ o xƬngrĆ©n, fēichĆ”ng gĒŽnxiĆØ.) Translation: I want to have almonds, please, thank you very much. However, there's a mistake in the chart because the coconut isn't a nut. Instead, it's a coconut fruit of the coconut tree, of the coconut palm family. The song was written by Filipino musician Ryan Cayabyab.  Now, it's time to enjoy learning Chinese through learning about n...

Using the Credentials Fallacy to Dismiss Anti-Protectionist, Pro-FDI Arguments

GarthBox I guess it's time for another post, isn't it? I'd like to say that I'm no super-expert in my field. I could remember one time I started talking about the need for constitutional reform. What I always choose to speak about first is the need to liberalize the economy, let more FDIs come in, and allow FDIs to own 100% of their businesses . Instead,  get shot down by arguments like, "Why let them invest here? Only they will be rich!" Even worse, they'll have  the credentials fallacy which can go with these kinds of insults that I can get every now and then: "Shut up! You're not an economist!" "Do you know Sonny Africa of IBON Foundation graduated from the London School of Economics and you didn't?" "Do you have a degree from the University of the Philippines, Ateneo De Manila University, or any of the Greenbelt universities?" "The school you graduated from is not one of the hardest to enter!" "You ...

Why I Support Taiwanese Politician Yeh Yi Jin's Proposal for Taiwan to Drop Zhuyin Entirely (in Favor of Pinyin)

Taiwan News It may be news from 2018 (meaning, five years ago) but as a person who sees the importance of Mandarin in the international market, I still want to react. Not surprisingly, Yeh Yi Jin lost the Tainan mayoral bid because of her controversial statement to abolish Zhuyin from Taiwan altogether . She may have lost the race but I'm still supporting her for this. It's not because I kept failing hard in Zhuyin back in my days. It's because I feel that as time goes on, some things need to be dropped like asking students to submit their reports written via typewriter or asking documents to be faxed when email (and modern standard mail) are more reliable. Like I argued with an investment before, I said, "You can't fax a book. Can I just mail it?" The bank kept arguing it had to be faxed. Unfortunately stubborn boomers, stubborn boomers, everywhere, right? From The Free China Post , this is what's said about Yeh's argument: Yeh argues that using zhuyi...

The STUPIDITY of Insisting that Equity Restrictions in the 1987 Constitution of the Philippines Exist for "National Security"

As the call for economic charter change goes on, I feel the need to educate some people with common sense . I'm reading comments on Facebook that 60-40 (or any similar ownership restrictions) is for the "security of the Philippines" or that certain sectors can't be allowed 100% ownership on the part of the MNC. Once again, do I need to remind people for the nth time that 100% FDI ownership is all about share ownership ? Sadly, many Filipinos misunderstand what 100% FDI means (read here ). What 100% FDI ownership means is that MNCs don't need to look for a Filipino partner, only to be burdened with having to give up 60% (or more) of the net profits after taxes  and they only keep 40% (or less). That's why I called such an arrangement as overpriced rent (read here ). Some of these people I ran into on Facebook (of all places) are too beholden to Atty. Hilario G. Davide Jr. It was last 2018 when Davide Jr. also said that the Philippines may become a "colony ...

When the Education Cares TOO MUCH About Grades, Schools Produce Idiots Instead of Intellectuals

During the pandemic, I was left in limbo thinking about my poor performance under K+10. It was something to think about that a classmate of mine who was both a summa cum laude and an honor student, ended up posting on his wall, "Students cheat because the education system cares more about grades instead of learning." The class salutatorian of our batch even commented about the good old days. I always had that feeling of insecurity and envy towards people better than me. But as Warren Edward Buffet would say, "Don't hate successful people. Learn from them instead." One of them is currently a teacher and the other is in Canada. I thought about my insecurities especially when I used to believe I was descended from a fine scholar and my family was a family of scholars.  I remembered the time I was taking MBA and got conned. I was asked, "Is that what MBA taught you?" I got touchy and ended up admitting, eventually, that I was only taking MBA for the presti...