Skip to main content

The Difference Between Capitalism and Commercialism

Dreamstime.com

People tend to hate capitalism without knowing what it means. More often than not, capitalism is often confused with commercialism. However, we must know the difference between the two. It's very crucial to learn what the difference is aside from the spelling. We need to take a view of two socio-economic systems and why one isn't the other.

Let's define capitalism in its plain simple terms

Capitalism is simply defined by the Investopedia as:
...an economic system in which private individuals or businesses own capital goods. The production of goods and services is based on supply and demand in the general market—known as a market economy—rather than through central planning—known as a planned economy or command economy.

In short, capitalism's focus is that private individuals or businesses are in charge of production. In turn, these businessmen fill in the supply and demand gap of the market. The supply and demand gap starts from basic goods to goods you want. Part of the supply and demand gap is people looking for jobs. People will be looking for jobs and those who own the capital provide the jobs. Capital is used in hiring people, buying machines, maintenance, paying bills, and all expenses related to the company. The net profit is based on money left after revenues are deducted from all expenses which include operation expenses, accounts payable, and taxes. Any good entrepreneur will pay their workers well, buy the best equipment, pay all their accounts payable, and pay taxes. This is the net income after taxes which is the wealth of the capitalist.

Research Gate

The model above by Adam Smith shows the allocation of capital. In short, the capital is meant to be distributed. Capital is placed on the means of production which includes labor and material. Finished products are sold to consumers. Money is generated in the process which goes to two ways--back to the operating budget and the net profits after taxes of the owners. To say that the workers own the means of production is stupid. The workers are partakers of the means of production and must be treated well such as proper pay and good working conditions.

Capitalism is the default means by which businesses and markets operate. That's why they must be regulated by ethics and government. Any good entrepreneur is not just concerned about profits. That's why business ethics subjects are taught in business school. Business in itself is a healthy competition--not some bloody gladiatorial struggle as leftists and communists may want to present it. That's why the government exists to present laws such as intellectual property rights, labor laws (which include compensation), consumer act, fair competition act, environmental laws, and every law designed to prevent misuse and abuse of capital. There are departments like the Department of Trade and Industry (DTI) and the Department of Labor and Employment (DOLE) to regulate capitalism as healthy competition. Treat them like judges in a contest who disqualify people who break the rules. 

With all the rules set, the capitalist must think creatively about how to win profits without breaking the rules. A capitalist wants to sell more but there are rules such as environmental rules to follow. A capitalist may start to think that a clean-up drive and being a role model in environmentally-friendly business practices would be good. A capitalist may open not just to compete but to also fill in the demand. It's pretty much like how Jollibee and Bo's Coffee Club are foreign-inspired. The desire for burgers and coffee gets filled in. Breaking the rules such as illegal dumping, 

Now, let's see what commercialism is really all about

iStock Photo

In contrast, commercialism is defined by Investopedia as:

...the idea that increasing the consumption of goods and services purchased in the market is always a desirable goal and that a person's wellbeing and happiness depend fundamentally on obtaining consumer goods and material possessions. In an economic sense, it is related to the predominantly Keynesian idea that consumer spending is the key driver of the economy and that encouraging consumers to spend is a major policy goal. From this point of view, consumerism is a positive phenomenon that fuels economic growth.

In short, commercialism is capitalism gone wrong. There's room for ethics and socio-economics in capitalism. However, when you go into a commercialized mindset--all you care about is profit even if it means doing what's wrong. It means that the focus is more on quantity than quality. When a service becomes commercialized--it's more focused on money than customer satisfaction. It's all about the accumulation of capital than the proper use of capital. It would only focus on getting the money now instead of thinking long-term. Some people who do this are either stingy or spendthrift people. A stingy person's only concern is to hoard money like there's no tomorrow. The other's only concern is to get as much money as possible to splurge on. These people will do anything to either hoard money to splurge on it at the expense of others. One may underpay workers to make a profit. The other may cheat customers to make a profit. Either way, that's where commercialism is a failure. It's because capital is a force of good unless misused and abused. 

That's why a certain degree of government intervention is still necessary to prevent commercialism. A capitalist system allows private ownership of goods. However, the government may want to seldom intervene with some rules. One involves setting a ceiling price or suggested retail price (SRP) for necessities to protect buyers. It's like you may buy a gallon of distilled water at PHP 50.00 because it's within the SRP. The government would have permission to call the attention to capitalists who overcharge or overprice beyond the SRP. The government also has the duty to call the attention to any capitalist with abusive labor practices and engages in destructive production methods. It's all about capitalism with reasonable restraint. Commercialism is all about capitalism without any restraint. 

References 

"Capital" by Marshall Hargrave, reviewed by Bryan Barnier, fact-checked by Yarilet Perez (Updated: April 3, 2022)

"Capitalism" by The Investopedia Team, reviewed by Marguerita Cheng, fact-checked by Pete Rathburn

"Consumerism" by Adam Hayes, reviewed by Robert C. Kelly, fact-checked by Kristin Rohrs Schmitt

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Accepting Foreign Investments Isn't About Relying Solely on Foreigners

  One of the biggest common mistakes about foreign investments is that it's all about "relying solely on foreigners" or "it's not going to develop the national industry". I agree that relying solely on foreign investments is not good. It's because if there are no local suppliers of local raw materials--foreign investments may have to rely purely on importation which isn't a good thing. Meanwhile, a nation will develop its agriculture and the like to provide raw materials for all kinds of buyers. It's pretty much a two-way street when it comes to investment. The late Lee Kuan Yew also talked about greening up Singapore along the way before it progressed. Singapore accepted foreign investments while it was still a third-world. However, it didn't neglect its own local industries. Reading through Chapter 4 of From Third World to First will tell us lessons about foreign investments. Lee saw them as the opportunity to bring in jobs, teach new skill...

The Filipino First Policy May Actually be Encouraging Dummy Investors Instead (Even with the Anti-Dummy Law)

I wrote a post where I discussed whether or not Alice Guo (and I heard her real name is supposedly Guo Hua Ping) should be a reason to say "No to economic charter change." A certain idiot I've dubbed Porky Madugo even wrote this on his Facebook account: Back on topic, I would like to emphasize that the Filipino First Policy may actually be encouraging dummy investors instead of discouraging them. Some people may use Alice to say, "See, I told you so, you (insert demeaning name)! If Alice can enter so easily, what about we allow 100% FDI and China buy us all!" That's the logic of that certain Porky Madugo, whose name and picture I blocked, despite my immense dislike for his stupidity. If Alice has been faking it  by lying she's a Filipino citizen (and sadly, this incident has been used to justify hatred against Chinese Filipinos), then the real root cause is this. The Filipino First Policy makes it too difficult for foreigners to do business in the Phili...

COMMUNIST Vietnam Has Defeated DEMOCRATIC Philippines Again This 2025

Cổng thông tin Trung ương Đoàn TNCS Hồ Chí Minh A few days ago, I wrote about warning Filipinos that they shouldn't wait for more unmitigated typhoon disasters, before realizing that the Filipino First Policy isn't working ! There's a statement that says, "Just because being tanga (inattentive) is libre (free), doesn't mean you should be tanga!"  Analyzing the different policies: why policies  matter I found a Business World article on my Facebook news feed discussing the Vietnamese economy . In fact, it would be better to share some hard truths that the article offers about what really went wrong with the  democratic Philippines compared to Communist Vietnam : DIVERGENT ECONOMIC MODELS Vietnam pursued an export-oriented manufacturing strategy which has proven significantly more successful over the past half century than the Philippines’ service-heavy, remittances-dependent model . Export performance alone tells a compelling story. Vietnam’s exports amount ...

Profood International Corporation's Calamansi Ginger Grean Tea Concentrate

I'm someone who always buys local and imported food products. However, I tend to buy local where I go because eating local is usually more beneficial. I was buying some stuff last Sunday. I found this product which I haven't heard of yet. It's called Calamansi Ginger Green Tea. If South Koreans have their Honey Citron, then maybe we can say Filipinos have Calamansi Ginger Green Tea concentrate, which also contains honey.  I gave it a shot, and it gives some relief for the throat. I drank Ginga Ginger Brew after I caught Omicron. That was the time when COVID-19 would eventually "get us all". I was looking for Ginga ginger powder but I wasn't able to find it. Fortunately, this food product ws available and it's helping me. I tend to get throat problems whenever the weather changes too much! I would drink it either lukewarm or cold, due to the weather conditions. The combination of ginger and calamansi helped me feel better. I would like to recommend this foo...

Alice Guo's Conviction Should NEVER be a Call to Shut Down Constitutional Reform

The Alice Guo saga seems to have come to an end, right? That's, unless of course something happens and she escapes again. This always made me laugh when I realized that, as I was writing my articles, I came across a Vietnamese girl named Ha Thi Thu Trang, aka Ha Trang, who resembles Alice. Right now, Ha Trang could come to the Philippines for a vacation and not get mistaken for the same person. Back on the topic, I would like to point out that I actually wrote a post on whether or not using Alice's controversy should be a call to shut down constitutional reform . Alice's now in jail, what's next?! I would like to let people know in advance, I'm not here to demolish Senator Maria Theresa "Risa" Baraquel-Hontiveros' efforts in getting Alice arrested. In fact, I feel grateful (in part) that Risa managed to expose Alice's lies, along with Senator Sherwin "Win" Ting Gatchalian in exposing Alice's dubious records. However, I'm going to...

"I Couldn't Remember Why Vietnam Exceeded the Philippines Last COVID-19!" Might Be the "Best Answer" Ever

24h.com I wasn't planning on blogging today. However, I saw from my Facebook feeds, I found something in interesting on the ANC 24/7 Facebook page. This was what I found: I read the full story on the ABS-CBN website. One reason why I'm critical of ABS-CBN is how they're very anti-reform. They tend to treat the 1987 Constitution of the Philippines as if it's so holy and pure, as if not one provision   of it must be amended! Oftentimes, Atty. Hilario G. Davide Jr. and/or Atty. Christian Monsod, are frequently featured when it comes to the welfare of the Philippines. Now, I'd like to share an excerpt from the ABS-CBN website, which makes me cringe.  Balisacan replied that the pandemic caused a bigger contraction in the Philippine economy compared to Vietnam .  “First, Vietnam over the last decade has been growing faster than the Philippines. Second, during the 2020 pandemic, our economy contracted by almost 10 percent. Whereas Vietnam contracted only a little. That pa...

My Personal Opinion on the Recent Universal Robina Incident

I was doing some news readings and I found out about the death of a certain Stephen Corilla. The incident happened in the Universal Robina Corporation's factory in Mandaue a few days ago. It really chilled my bones to read these details which I'll share from Sunstar : POLICE are set to investigate a food and beverage plant in Barangay Tabok, Mandaue City after one of its workers was killed on duty while cleaning a pulverizer machine Thursday afternoon, June 2, 2022. Cpl. Glenn Bordalba of the Mandaue City Police Office Station 3 in Barangay Basak who is leading the investigation told SunStar Cebu Monday, June 6, that they will visit the Universal Robina Corp. (URC) Mandaue City plant in Tabok on Tuesday, June 7, to investigate the matter. Bordalba added that they have not started the investigation yet as they were not allowed entry to the site by the URC management after the incident was reported to them. An approval from the corporation’s consultant is needed for the police to...

In a FREE Market, You Can Opt Out of Adobe Photoshop for Affinity Photo

Let's face it that the market will never be all yours. That's what Adobe needs to learn as it still continues, it's really bad business practices. It's a good thing that I asked around before getting Affinity Photo. Adobe Photoshop's usage is really plain bad. In economics, there's such a thing as the law of substitutes. If something is too expensive, get a more affordable substitute. It's like,  don't get an iPhone if you can't afford to buy an iPhone. It's like why I would still prefer a Samsung or a Xiaomi over an iPhone. An iPhone is too expensive for my taste, even for a guy with somewhat expensive taste! As I look into Adobe's subscription (which will cost me PHP 3,000+ per month) vs. a one-shot purchase for Affinity in my Windows account, we know which is better. Affinity Photo works in nearly the same way as Photoshop does. My only minor complaint is that I couldn't make animated GIFs with Affinity Photo alone. Hopefully, Canva...

Kabataan Partylist SERIOUSLY Needs to Learn BASIC Business from the Ho Chi Minh Communist Youth Union

Foreign Trade University A few days ago, I wrote about Kabataan Partylist needing to learn economics from the Ho Chi Minh Communist Youth Union . Otherwise, I'll continue using the Vietnam Youth Union for convenience. Speaking of which, the Foreign Trade University in Vietnam is actually a government-owned university (read here ). For this post, I decided to expand on a point, saying that Kabataan Partylist needs to learn from the Vietnam Youth Union on entrepreneurship . I pretty get jealous of the Vietnam Youth Union members with their practical early immersion.  The  National Defence Journal   of Vietnam gives out this important detail of the Vietnam Youth Union:  Fifth, enhancing the support of young intellectuals to get access to opportunities of work, research, develop ideas, products, and start-up to legitimately enrich themselves, the community and the country. Support the implementation of startup ideas and projects of young intellectuals in practice, making...

Filipino First Policy Also Responsible That ONLY 2/10 Pinoys Have Emergency Funds

Yes, it's been a day since Typhoon Tino. It was a stormy, scary time, and I thought about how expenses were piling up after I was hit by Typhoon Odette . Thankfully, I had contingency savings at that time. However, with Uswan moving upwards and entering another area of the Philippine Area of Responsibility, I considered the issue of emergency savings. I thought about how Christmas can be the most stressful time of the year, with issues such as traffic caused by last-minute Christmas shopping . This time, I thought about some not-so-surprising statistics on Filipinos. It turns out that   only 2/10  Filipinos have enough emergency savings .  This should be considered disturbing,  and this is another thing I failed to consider in my younger, more foolish years, according to the Philippine Star : Commissioned by insurance firm EastWest Ageas, the PURPLE Report conducted by consumer intelligence company NielsenIQ showed that most Filipinos only have P50,000 in emerg...