Skip to main content

The Philippines Needs Economic Charter Change Now!

Listen to him and those who think alike, not the naysayers!

I created this blog without the intent of writing politics into it. I for one am for constitutional reform every now and then. One of these provisions of the constitution I believe that really needs reform is the economic provision. I may be no economist or constitutionalist but I can see (to a certain extent) where it's going. I've read the Filipino First Policy by Carlos P. Garcia. The aim was to make sure that at the end of the day, Filipinos will become the majority of the shareholders. However, decades of Filipino First Policy have caused us to be left behind. That's why I believe it's time to change it. 

Naysayers against economic constitutional reform

However, some people (such as Hilario Davide Jr.) would end up saying something like, "I don't believe that anything needs to be amended. The 1987 Constitution is the best in the world." Davide Jr. even went on to say that the 1987 Constitution of the Philippines is the only constitution that says the public office is a public trust. Please, Thomas Jefferson had long said that, and he was born way before Davide Jr. was born! Singapore's Public Trustee Act of 1915 was there before Davide Jr. was born into the world. Any good constitution in the world will specify itself as a public trust. Ironic that Davide was a diplomat to the United Nations (UN) for some time just like Singaporean-Indian Kishore Mahbubani. I'm simply amazed at the ignorance that Davide had told reporters that removing 60-40 will turn the Philippines into a "colony of foreign businessmen". This really makes me laugh because Mahbubani was also a UN Diplomat like he was. I even wonder how Mahbubani would react if Davide Jr. would say to him in Singapore, "If the Philippines will remove 60-40--we will become a colony of foreign businessmen." Mahbubani might end up saying, "Are you trying to kid me? Didn't you listen to me? Foreign investment create jobs, bring in capital, bring in markets, develop and train our labor force. Look at Singapore now." 

Teodoro Casino of Bayan Muna even wrote his opinion piece in Rappler about how charter change reverses the gains of EDSA. I would confess that I wouldn't be able to blog right now without EDSA. However, it's best to point out the mistakes after EDSA and rectify them. I'm amazed that Casino himself where says that without definite limits, foreign investors will "conquer" the Philippines. Casino operates with a very leftist view. Having been a lawyer and lawmaker--is he totally aware that the government still can control foreign investments even if there are no definite limits such as 60-40? Who says that the state isn't involved? The state is involved when it allows foreign investors to do business provided that they follow business laws and pay taxes. All Casino does is talk and talk without results.

IBON Foundation is another. I'm amazed at how Sonny Africa, a graduate of the London School of Economics, even dares to say that the latest industrialized such as South Korea, Taiwan, and China allegedly had lesser foreign investments in their periods of economic takeoff than the Philippines does today. I wonder where Africa got his empirical evidence to back up his claim? That's why I really can't even take IBON Foundation seriously. True, they have gathered numerical data but they also tend to engage in pie-in-the-sky statistics. A good example is was it the fault of outing Philippine President Rodrigo R. Duterte that gasoline prices are higher? Did they not consider the war in Ukraine that's going on? Worse, people at IBON have that deadly obsession with ayuda or government handouts--something that's also holding back the nation from development. 

The naysayers will do everything to stop it. There have been many lies such as that only foreign investors will get rich, that they will rob the resources, exploit the people, that it automatically means environmental destruction, etc. Yet, North Korea and Venezuela, two isolationist countries have been suffering from higher degrees of pollution. Meanwhile, China has had an active role in trying to curb air pollution and they have the money to do so. Though, I still feel China needs to lift the ban on Google and Facebook, not to meddle too much in political views (hence causing Lotte to leave). North Korea and Venezuela are practicing economic nationalism but at what cost? The empirical data of these two countries are working against the naysayers. These naysayers either believe their lies or are lying for their own convenience. 

Why I stand for economic charter change

Constitutional reform or charter change can be good or bad. If we're talking about the 1973 constitutional convention--it's a bad thing. Benigno Simeon A. Aquino Jr. otherwise known as Ninoy revealed that it was a fake parliament, to begin with. Any real parliament would have a ceremonial president. Instead, it was revealed by the late Lee Kuan Yew in his book From Third World to First that the late Cesar Virata was no political leader. Virata was picked by Ferdinand E. Marcos Sr. to be the prime minister. A real parliamentary system would have the people vote for the party with the party having picked its prime minister. The majority party becomes the government and its lead candidate becomes the prime minister. The minority party becomes the opposition and its lead candidate becomes the opposition leader. If the Philippines were a parliament today--Ferdinand "Bongbong" R. Marcos Jr. would become the prime minister and Maria Leonor "Leni" Gerona-Robredo would become the opposition leader. Both leaders will face off against each other weekly. 

Sure, making amendments had helped the late Benigno Simeon. C. Aquino creates a rising tiger. However, salaries are still not as high as in the neighboring ASEAN countries. There are still other sectors stuck on the negative list. Sure, Duterte may have signed but as economist Andrew James Masigan says, it's long overdue. Masigan, a critic of Duterte, deserves some praise for pointing out mistakes in Duterenomics on where they needed to be fixed. Unlike IBON Foundation, Masigan hasn't wasted his education at De La Salle University (unlike a certain Juan Dalisay Jr. who's a member of the Facebook group, CoRRECT Moderated Public Forum) and has taken his master's degree in the University of Asia and the Pacific--something I can only dream of. Masigan had even pointed out why we need economic charter change. Masigan is a proponent of constitutional reform. As Masigan says, charter change can be a good thing if done right. What I'm supporting is a charter change for the better and not all about charter change for the sake of it. 

There are still laws regarding businesses, after all. All businesses, whether local or foreign, will be subject to business rules. There are labor laws, environmental laws, intellectual property laws, and other laws to follow. Any business is required to be in agreement with the state that the business is to follow these rules. There are penalties to follow such as hefty fines, closure, imprisonment, and in the case of foreign investors, deportation like bad tenants who are kicked out. These laws will guarantee that foreign investors will not exploit the locals or destroy businesses directly. The only businesses that die (whether local or foreign) are those that don't evolve. If an incompetent foreign investor enters the Philippines then it will die under the feet of competent Filipino businessmen. If a Filipino investor is incompetent then it will die under the feet of any investor whether Filipino or foreign. Filipino businesses have their choice to either (1) evolve and match up to foreign investors, or (2) whine and eventually perish in competition. Either they say, "More competition? Well, I've got new customers and new networks!" or "Waaaaahhhh! I hate competition!" These choices will determine if they will fall under the mercy of foreign investors or if they will match up to them. Then again, there are also laws such as the Fair Competition Act that make sure all competitors are protected from unhealthy competition.

The issue is always supply and demand. Services are expensive and of lower quality because of supply and demand. Do you expect a duopoly in telecommunications to provide fast and affordable Internet to all 7,107 islands? Do you expect so few power companies to actually provide affordable electricity and restore power after a disaster at a faster pace? Once again, it's a bottleneck as these companies are biting more than they can chew. Having more competition will not only force local investors to improve their services--it will also fill in the supply and demand gap. Part of the supply and demand gap is employment demands. As Mahbubani says, foreign investors will also provide jobs for the people. These foreign investors will be registered and subjected to local law which means they'll have to pay taxes. They will also employ people and improve the economy through more taxes. This, in turn, will hopefully increase the minimum wage and the standard of living. True, the prices of goods will eventually go up (due to salaries going up) but it will be manageable. It's not exploitation at all in contrast to what Venezuela and North Korea are doing as they exploit their own people. 

If we want to prove Filipinos are great--let them face competition. Let the Philippines follow its neighboring ASEAN countries such as Malaysia, Indonesia, Taiwan, and Singapore. What we need is more than a rising tiger. Let foreign investors arrive, let them get registered, and let's follow the Singaporean model. Don't say Singapore is too small that it can't be followed. Deng Xiaoping of China, followed the Singapore model. Look where Deng brought China into. The Philippines should lay aside its Pinoy Pride economic nationalism for good. 

References

Books

"From Third World to First--The Singapore Story: 1965-2000) by Lee Kuan Yew
Harpers Collins Publishers

Videos

"The Singapore economic model - VPRO documentary - 2009"  by VRPO Documentary (September 8, 2018)

Websites

"Basic Obligation of Public Service" 


"Carlos P. Garcia, Third State of the Nation Address, January 25, 1960"

"From ‘Airpocalypse’ to Olympic Blue: China’s Air Quality Transformation" by Lili Pike

"Long overdue laws finally passed" by Andrew J. Masigan (April 06, 2022)

"Lotte to pull out of China, focus on Southeast Asia" (Posted: May 23, 2022, 08:39 A.M., Updated: May 23, 2022, 02:16 P.M.)

"NINOY AQUINO’S SPEECH IN LOS ANGELES"

"No Mavericks Among Economic Top Guns" by Sonny Africa

"New report pieces together toll of environmental damage in Venezuela in 2021" by Maxwell Radwin (April 20, 2022)

"North Korea: The Missing Link in Northeast Asia’s Air Pollution Fight" By Jihyun Cha and Taeheon Lee (June 11, 2019)

"[OPINION] Duterte’s Cha-Cha reverses gains of EDSA" by Teodoro Casino (March 02, 2018)

"PUBLIC TRUSTEE ACT 1915: 2020 REVISED EDITION" 
https://sso.agc.gov.sg/Act/PTA1915

"Understanding Charter Change" by Andrew J. Masigan (January 22, 2018)

Labels

Labels:

Popular posts from this blog

Why I Feel "Play-to-Earn" Games are Too Good to be True

I've been running into ads that promise the "play to earn" games even before the pandemic. Some of them featured a game that all I needed was to merge this and that or pop bubbles and boom--I get money! I remembered finding ways to make money online and they encouraged gambling. There's always the rule of thumb in finances--if it's too good to be true then run  from it. It reminds me of how I get irritated by those fake game ads and now these new fake game ads? It's already bad enough I was duped into downloading Gardenscape with the fake ads. Now, these fake ads are probably the worst offenders over mobile demos that irritate us with annoying display of stupidity.  Any gamer who probably owned a Playstation 3 or an XBox 360 (or any seventh generation console) would remember having to buy credits to buy extra content. A buyer may have had to buy Playstation Points (or the like) to purchase additional content. Later, there's the pay to play online which a p...
Read more

Why I Support Taiwanese Politician Yeh Yi Jin's Proposal for Taiwan to Drop Zhuyin Entirely (in Favor of Pinyin)

Taiwan News It may be news from 2018 (meaning, five years ago) but as a person who sees the importance of Mandarin in the international market, I still want to react. Not surprisingly, Yeh Yi Jin lost the Tainan mayoral bid because of her controversial statement to abolish Zhuyin from Taiwan altogether . She may have lost the race but I'm still supporting her for this. It's not because I kept failing hard in Zhuyin back in my days. It's because I feel that as time goes on, some things need to be dropped like asking students to submit their reports written via typewriter or asking documents to be faxed when email (and modern standard mail) are more reliable. Like I argued with an investment before, I said, "You can't fax a book. Can I just mail it?" The bank kept arguing it had to be faxed. Unfortunately stubborn boomers, stubborn boomers, everywhere, right? From The Free China Post , this is what's said about Yeh's argument: Yeh argues that using zhuyi...
Read more

The Lesson of "Bad Genius" is More Than Just "Cheating Never Pays Off"

Sometimes, much truth can be told in fiction, right? Talk about how the great Jose Rizal revealed much truth in his fictional novels Noli Me Tangere and El Filibusterismo . The digital age today would create more entertaining media. I may encourage book reading over movie watching. However, some movies may do more than entertain. They can also address a real issue. It was said that a cheating scandal in China inspired the producers Jira Maligool and Vanridee Pongsittisak to create the film  Bad Genius . Right now, there's even a TV series presumably because a movie can't always deliver the message one wants. How does the whole thing go? I was inspired to watch this film because of comments from a Facebook friend's post. The post also talked about how students cheat because the system cares more about grades than learning.  As the world becomes more global, exposure to Thai cinema is definitely not surprising. Sure, one can talk about the South Korean wave or the increasin...
Read more

My Experience with Pyramid Scams in College Up to Present

  Often, a pyramid is often confused with a Ponzi scheme. Both are illegal schemes but there's the difference. A pyramid scam emphasizes on recruitment and selling of products. A Ponzi scheme guarantees high returns for short periods. Both operate similarly but scam people differently. Both should be shunned and be considered  defective baskets.  I remembered my college days at the University of San Carlos-Main Campus (USC-Main) when I was still a newbie with money. It sucks really when high school didn't teach us financial literacy and people seemingly need to take commerce to do so. One of the biggest scams that hit even graduate school students was the pyramid scam. Even worse, some of those who got suckered with ongoing financial scams were graduate school students of the School of Business and Economics! The Investor.gov website from the United States of America (USA) would tell us these are the hallmarks of a pyramid scam: These are some of the hallmarks of a pyram...
Read more

When the Education Cares TOO MUCH About Grades, Schools Produce Idiots Instead of Intellectuals

During the pandemic, I was left in limbo thinking about my poor performance under K+10. It was something to think about that a classmate of mine who was both a summa cum laude and an honor student, ended up posting on his wall, "Students cheat because the education system cares more about grades instead of learning." The class salutatorian of our batch even commented about the good old days. I always had that feeling of insecurity and envy towards people better than me. But as Warren Edward Buffet would say, "Don't hate successful people. Learn from them instead." One of them is currently a teacher and the other is in Canada. I thought about my insecurities especially when I used to believe I was descended from a fine scholar and my family was a family of scholars.  I remembered the time I was taking MBA and got conned. I was asked, "Is that what MBA taught you?" I got touchy and ended up admitting, eventually, that I was only taking MBA for the presti...
Read more

#ThrowbackThursdays: Refuting This Deadly Anti-Free Trade Postcard from the 1910s

Anti Free Trade Postcard From 1910. Corbis via Getty Images / Getty Images I was thinking about a few more anti-protectionist posts and I found this "antique" postcard. Not that I have a physical copy of it (which would be aged by now) but that it's from the 1910s. That would already be 112 years ago when this postcard was first made. Unfortunately, this post card is still used as deceptive propaganda even some time. What should be interesting is that the 1918 Spanish flu pandemic and the COVID-19 pandemic had protectionists taking opportunity over it. After 1918, the world went into the Stock Market Crash of 1929 followed up by the Great Depression of that same year.  Events after the postcard that proved the postcard a lie The postcard promoted two lies that protectionism (in the form of tariffs) creates prosperity and happiness while free trade creates unemployment and misery. Here's a definition of tariff from ThoughtCo : The most commonly applied protectionist ...
Read more

Cherry's the Spice's Hyderabadi Style Cooking from the Heart

Sugbo.PH I remembered driving across Talamban sometime before the COVID-19 pandemic. One of the restaurants that caught my curiosity was called The Spice or Cherry's the Spice. The letter "i" is shaped like chili to give you this note that the restaurant is targeted towards people who enjoy spicy food. Yet, it has become very popular among Filipino customers. Cherry's the Spice was another one I was curious about but not ready to anticipate the different regions of cooking. It's pretty much cooking in Region V - Bicol Region is different from Region VII - Visayas. This restaurant had a cottage-like feel. This restaurant has won the best Indian restaurant award from Sunstar Cebu .    TripAdvisor The type of food here is similar yet different to Bollywood. Bollywood is pretty much North Indian for most of its cuisine. Cherry's the Spice focuses on Hyderabad-style cooking which I compare to the Bicol region. If I'm not wrong, some of its food has fresh coconu...
Read more

How I Believe the Public Service Act of 2022 Will Benefit the Philippine Business and Economic Environment

One of the greatest news for the Philippines is the Public Service Act of 2022. The following can be read from the Philippine News Agency regarding President Rodrigo R. Duterte's signing of the new law into action: President Rodrigo Roa Duterte on Monday signed into law a measure amending the Public Service Act (PSA), allowing up to 100 percent foreign ownership of public services in the country. Republic Act (RA) No. 11659 or "An Act Amending Commonwealth Act No. 146 otherwise known as the Public Service Act” as amended was signed by Duterte in a ceremony at the Rizal Hall, Malacañan Palace in the presence of lawmakers and other officials. Under the amended PSA, the telecommunications, railways, expressways, airports, and shipping industries will be considered public services, allowing up to 100 percent foreign ownership in these sectors. Duterte also led the ceremonial presentation of newly enacted laws namely RA 11647 which amends the Foreign Investments Act; RA 11650, whic...
Read more

Axie Infinity's Poor Security Should Also Give Me Another Good Reason to Say "No Thanks!"

I haven't returned to writing about Axie Infinity because I didn't get into it. I may have been foolish enough to get scammed by a family friend. However, I started to think that, "If it's too good to be true then don't buy it!" I always wanted instant gratification out of greed and impatience. I think two reasons why investors get into bad deals are because of greed and impatience--wanting the money now. It's also why some people join the drug cartels. Right now, Axie Infinity may have been so last 2018 (and I keep getting a lot of irritating play-to-earn ads on the Internet) but it doesn't mean it's going to be that sustainable.  On March 30, 2022, CNBC also reported on this incident where more than USD 600 million was stolen from the makers of Axie Infinity : The makers of one of the most popular blockchain-based online games said Tuesday that hackers were able to steal assets worth about $625 million from the gaming company and its players. The...
Read more

Learning from the Indian Economic Legacy of Third World to First

CNN Today is Indian Independence Day. It's very easy to look down at India that's until you realize that it went from an impoverished former British colony to an emerging country. It's 75 years of India's independence from Great Britain. I feel it's time to write another economics-related post for this blog. Before that, you may want to read about Deng Xiaoping's real great leap forward (read here ). Though, if you don't mind then you can start reading this post which I will talk about in this post. CNN has Rhea Mogul shares this insight on India's economic growth : Rise of an economic power   Following independence, India was in chaos. Reeling from a bloody partition that killed between 500,000 and 2 million people, and uprooted an estimated 15 million more, it was synonymous with poverty .   Average life expectancy in the years after the British left was just 37 for men and 36 for women, and only 12% of Indians were literate. The country's GDP was ...
Read more