Skip to main content

Using the Credentials Fallacy to Dismiss Anti-Protectionist, Pro-FDI Arguments

GarthBox

I guess it's time for another post, isn't it? I'd like to say that I'm no super-expert in my field. I could remember one time I started talking about the need for constitutional reform. What I always choose to speak about first is the need to liberalize the economy, let more FDIs come in, and allow FDIs to own 100% of their businesses. Instead,  get shot down by arguments like, "Why let them invest here? Only they will be rich!" Even worse, they'll have the credentials fallacy which can go with these kinds of insults that I can get every now and then:

    1. "Shut up! You're not an economist!"
    2. "Do you know Sonny Africa of IBON Foundation graduated from the London School of Economics and you didn't?"
    3. "Do you have a degree from the University of the Philippines, Ateneo De Manila University, or any of the Greenbelt universities?"
    4. "The school you graduated from is not one of the hardest to enter!"
    5. "You just graduated from (insert school). I graduated from (insert prestigious University)."
    6. "I graduated from the Asian Institute of Management therefore I'm right!"
    7. "Do you know how many credentials I have! Check my Facebook account you (insert derogatory name)."
I wrote about social media gossip against Robin Padilla. The common argument was that they use Padilla's status as an ex-convinct therefore he can't lead the amendments. Arguments like calling him Boy Sili might further suggest their position is weakened. It's because using insults to win an argument is very uncalled for. Even worse, they tend to use Credits To The Owner (CTTO) a lot but who are they giving credit to? CTTO is something that I realize needs to be used sparingly. It's always better to give credit to the sources to see if they're valid or not. It's very easy to say, "Multiple studies show that FDI will destroy our countries. CTTO." Who's CTTO? Trust Me Bro Fact Checking Society? The MARITES School of Business and Economics? Intrigador Financials? 

To describe the credentials fallacy, the Effectiviology website explains it:

Explanation of the credentials fallacy

The credentials fallacy is a type of informal logical fallacy, since there is an issue with its premises, and namely with the premise that if someone doesn’t have credentials in a certain field, then any argument that they make can be immediately dismissed. This premise is problematic, since even though it can be appropriate to take credentials into account in some cases, it’s fallacious to assume that if someone doesn’t have appropriate credentials then their argument must necessarily be wrong.

Based on this, the credentials fallacy can be categorized as a genetic fallacy, since it focuses on the origin of the argument rather than on the argument itself. More specifically, it can be categorized as a type of ad hominem attack, since it personally targets the individual who is making the argument.

To further build up my authority, I can start citing valid sources like Claro M. Recto, the late Miriam Defensor-Santiago, the late Lee Kuan Yew, Mahathir Mohamad, the late Margaret Thatcher, the late Shinzo Abe, or Kishore Mahbubani (the founder of the Lee Kuan Yew School of Public Policy (LKYSPP) at the National University of Singapore (NUS)). I could read from the pages of LKY's book From Third World to First or cite from the LKYSPP to try and prove the Davide Jr. fanboy or that 1987 Constitution extremist that he or she is in the wrong. However, they will still shoot my argument to remove nonsense protectionist policies (such as the 60-40 equity deal) down simply because of my credentials.

We can now move to another example. Somebody is citing Hilario Davide Jr. to cite that FDI is bad and that it will colonize the Philippines. I would start to say, "No! That's not true!" The person citing Davide Jr. may say, "Are you a constitutionalist? Did any of your grandparents or parents help Davide frame the 1987 Constitution? If not then shut up!" 

The outcomes can be hilarious if the person still refuses to believe. The arguments can end up with more logical fallacies. I'm no expert in logic but it doesn't hurt for me to study it. I could think of these outcomes that can really be that stupid: 

  1. The use of the Appeal to the Masses (Argument Ad Populum). It can be like, "Majority of Filipinos still agree that the 1987 Constitution is the best in the world!" "Majority of Filipinos believe charter change is bad, therefore it must be bad!" What's ignored is that the majority is not always right. That's why a lot of people fall into scams because of Argument Ad Populum. 
  2. They can use the Genetic Fallacy argument accompanied by Ad Hominems to further down an argument. I could imagine it going something like, "Kishore Mahbuban is a smelly Indian! I'd listen to Davide over Mahbubani not only because he's my countryman but because he definitely isn't a smelly Indian!" 
  3. A couple of Red Herring arguments can be used like name-calling. It can be accompanied by an Appeal to Emotion fallacy such as the Trust Me Bro or (insert insult) style of argument. That should be considered the peak of the MARITES pyramid of learning (read here).
  4. Even worse, the Appeal to Emotion fallacy can end up like, "If you don't believe me! I will (insert physical threat)." It can go something like, "If you don't believe me that the Marcos Years was a parliamentary government, I will cut you up with my machete."
Evidence matters more than claims. It's possible anybody can keep singing and dancing to the tune "It's More Fun in the Philippines". The slogan was introduced during the time of the late former Philippine president, Benigno Simeno C. Aquino III. The slogan was copied from Switzerland. Anybody can say, "I see absolutely no need to amend the 1987 Constitution of the Philippines. It's the only constitution that is... blah blah blah..." Well, think about it all the blah blah blahs mean nothing if there's no evidence. Has the Philippines, as a country, really become a long-standing model like Singapore? One can argue from growth rate but growth rate alone will not determine things. A developed country may soon have a lower growth rate because of how long it's developed. An emerging country like the Philippines may have had a bigger growth rate during Aquino III's term since it was still rising up.

This reminds me that I took my MBA just for the sake of a credential. However, I soon found myself using the credentials fallacy just to look good. What really shocks people is how lousy the Philippine education system is. How is it that people with good academic records end up becoming so stupid? That's why even some people with good academic records now admit, "We learned nothing but to memorize! That's why students cheat in every way possible!" 

Some stubborn boomers are still stuck with their credentials. What's often ignored is that being an honor student back in the 1960s may become moot today. It's because the books and lessons back then were easier than they are today. Lessons have to get harder because new information is generated daily. What's the use of being an honor student if one's an honor student in a lower-standard school? I guess that's why they continue to get defensive is also because they think they're always right. They just can't stand it when a person of lower educational status beats them with the facts. Do they even realize that some of the facts are taken from people actually even better than them? 

I would like to ask what good did the credentials do? Did it make the Philippines a better country? Instead, more Filipinos are still flying abroad due to a lack of job opportunities. The public services are still costly and of bad quality. These credentialists would start giving nonsense solutions which have been proven, by common sense, to never work. Their credentials are best called "It's just a degree if you can't provide good results." 

Popular posts from this blog

Filipino First Policy Linked with Crab Mentality

Having sea crab yesterday or just eating crab, I always think of that old commercial in the 1990s. It was called, "Iwasan ang crab mentality." or "Avoid crab mentality." This makes me recall a scene when I was a child. I saw a pail full of mud crabs (called alimango in Filipino) and if one crab got out, the others pulled it down. The TV commercial showed how if the crabs got together, they could all escape their grizzly fate of becoming eaten for human consumption. Chefs are just lucky crabs pull each other down. However, it also shows that the crabs would rather all be cooked together than let that crab escape.  Unfortunately, crab mentality is one of the biggest problems in the Philippines. It's not all that unique among Filipinos. However, it doesn't Filipinos should ever take comfort in engaging in a crab mentality, just because other people do it . Here's an interesting excerpt from Inquirer   by Jerry Peres de Tagle PhD: Studies in human behavior ...

It's a Common, Broken New Year's Resolution Among Filipinos to Do Better with Their Finances and Economic Knowledge

Happy New Year, right? There's this statement in Cebuano that says, "Sa Disyembre nag lipay-lipay. Sa Enero, naglikay-likay." For non-Cebuano speakers, it means, "Enjoying all December. Fleeing in January." It's because of the bad habits that are common during the Christmas season. I wrote an entry talking about when a Merry Christmas leads to an Unhappy New Year . After Christmas vacation, it can be common to talk about New Year's Resolutions. Sadly, there are resolutions meant to be broken or resolutions on paper only. Several people finish high school, go to college, get a job, but never gain the necessary knowledge of economics and finances. Instead, they continue to live the same habits year after year. Even worse, the same foolish behavioral patterns get passed down f rom parent to child to grandchild. Still stuck with financial habits that put one in a financial dodo The New Year starts and it can get funny. I tend to hate December because of the ...

Rejoicing Over Filipino Businesses Getting 100% Ownership Abroad While Crying Over FDIs Getting Allowed to Own 100% Ownership

The Philippine senatorial elections are on, right? One of the many things candidates (regardless of party) need to hold is the need for economic reform. As  I continue discussing economic charter change, several objections are held. One of the objections is allowing 100% FDI--a subject often subjected to mockery. These mockeries can range from promoting colonial mentality, selling the Filipino to foreigners, borrowing money from abroad (which is definitely not investment, read here ), or even the ridiculous notion that FDI includes Filipino women dating foreigners (read here ). This time, I would like to address another hypocrisy. This time, it's all about Filipinos who rejoice that Filipino businesses are investing with 100% FDI ownership. All the while, this is crying foul when there's a law passed that will allow foreigners to own 100% FDI ownership , in the Philippines. This is a meme to expose the hypocrisy. Jollibee has 158 branches in Vietnam, which I assume happened bec...

The Recent Microsoft Global Outage Should be a Wake-Up Call to the Philippines' Need to Fix the 1987 Constitution's Economic Flaws

The Express Tribune The recent Microsoft Global Outage was caused by Crowdstrike. Since I'm no IT or CS expert--it's better if I let them talk in the news. From BBC News , here's a detail from Crowdstrike that reveals the root cause of the problem has been systemic with an update: This is still a little unclear. CrowdStrike is known for producing antivirus software, intended to prevent hackers from causing this very type of disruption. According to CrowdStrike boss George Kurtz, the issues are only impacting Windows PCs and no other operating systems, and were caused by a defect in a recent update . "The issue has been identified, isolated and a fix has been deployed," he said. "This is not a security incident or cyber-attack." What exactly was wrong with the update is yet to be revealed, but as a potential fix involves deleting a single file, it is possible that just one rogue file could be at the root of all the mayhem. Thankfully, those who created th...

Is Vietnam Getting More FDI Inflows than the Philippines, Because of Its Supposedly Better Fight Against Corruption?

Discussing international marketing or world economics with boomer Filipinos can be painful. Some people still believe in the Filipino First Policy. I cite Vietnam as an example of why economic charter change (called econ cha cha) should be done. Some people cite that Vietnam's increase in FDI is because of the fight against corruption. I don't deny Vietnam has a crackdown on corruption. I don't deny that fighting against corruption helps the economy. However, fighting corruption without the proper tools and not having economic development, is useless. Fighting corruption isn't a panacea or cure-all either.  Spanking is part of child discipline, not the whole of child discipline. People who only spank but never teach right and wrong, render spanking ineffective . Instead, look at Vietnam's economic policy vs. the Philippines' economic policy. Some people blame the following for the Philippines' lack of foreign investments, some things Vietnam also suffers fr...

Trying to Plan Out What to Do as a Bull Market Starts

I was laughing just thinking about ignorance about the bear and bull markets. Yes, we know about social media gossipers (seldom called a marites in Filipino) tend to spread gossip. I ran into several people panicking when the Philippine Stock Exchange Index (PSEi) was mostly red. Others would panic but Warren Edward Buffett recommends, "Be fearful when others are greedy. Be greedy when others are fearful." That's the best market timing. Some people do cost averaging because it's practically less risky in contrast to lump sum investing. Buffett recommends that non-technical people should periodically invest in a low-cost index fund over a period of ten years.  Now, the Philippine Star has an article by Wilson Sy, where the first paragraph talks about the Philippines' entry towards the bull market : Most stock markets have undergone a dramatic shift to start the year, transitioning from a bear market to a bull market. Peak inflation, a slower pace of interest rate h...

When the Education Cares TOO MUCH About Grades, Schools Produce Idiots Instead of Intellectuals

During the pandemic, I was left in limbo thinking about my poor performance under K+10. It was something to think about that a classmate of mine who was both a summa cum laude and an honor student, ended up posting on his wall, "Students cheat because the education system cares more about grades instead of learning." The class salutatorian of our batch even commented about the good old days. I always had that feeling of insecurity and envy towards people better than me. But as Warren Edward Buffet would say, "Don't hate successful people. Learn from them instead." One of them is currently a teacher and the other is in Canada. I thought about my insecurities especially when I used to believe I was descended from a fine scholar and my family was a family of scholars.  I remembered the time I was taking MBA and got conned. I was asked, "Is that what MBA taught you?" I got touchy and ended up admitting, eventually, that I was only taking MBA for the presti...

My Personal Opinion on the Recent Universal Robina Incident

I was doing some news readings and I found out about the death of a certain Stephen Corilla. The incident happened in the Universal Robina Corporation's factory in Mandaue a few days ago. It really chilled my bones to read these details which I'll share from Sunstar : POLICE are set to investigate a food and beverage plant in Barangay Tabok, Mandaue City after one of its workers was killed on duty while cleaning a pulverizer machine Thursday afternoon, June 2, 2022. Cpl. Glenn Bordalba of the Mandaue City Police Office Station 3 in Barangay Basak who is leading the investigation told SunStar Cebu Monday, June 6, that they will visit the Universal Robina Corp. (URC) Mandaue City plant in Tabok on Tuesday, June 7, to investigate the matter. Bordalba added that they have not started the investigation yet as they were not allowed entry to the site by the URC management after the incident was reported to them. An approval from the corporation’s consultant is needed for the police to...

My Experience with Tealive Cebu at the Ayala Central Bloc

I have tasted several foreign-owned tea shops. My first experience with tea shops was with Chatime (read here ). Now, I heard of this new coffee shop (or tea shop, take your pick) called Tealive. At first, I thought it was Taiwanese but when I Googled it--it was Malaysian. It made sense that the company uses only Halal-approved ingredients  since Malaysia has a huge Muslim population. The founder is Malaysian-Chinese businessman Bryan Loo of Loob Holdings. Loob here also means inside as the Tagalog language also derives from the Malay language. Tealive would later head to the Philippines. It would be like getting Filipinos closer to their Malaysian heritage after all.  The branches in Cebu include SM City, SM Seaside, and Ayala Central Bloc. The one I ate was at Ayala Central Bloc. Someone gave me a taste of their sandwich and their signature coffee. I was pretty much impressed that I decided to dine in there. I went to try their lychee tea and chees burger. For a note, their ...

Getting Stingy at the Cost of Fire Safety?

March is fire prevention month, right? If there are people who are too extravagant then I'd like to talk again about stingy people (read the article here ). I've tried growing up with the stingy vs. extravagant extremes. Some people become stingy even with the necessities. It's one thing to deny a child a children's party since it's a want . It's another thing to deny a child stuff they need all in the name of saving money . Even worse, some people may be more than stingy enough to ignore fire safety. A stingy person just wants to save. It's almost like the story of the Miser and His Gold or The Rich Miser . I really find these stories entertaining at the same time, irritating. The first story has the miser who hid his gold under the ground. Some people today are too distrustful of banks and investments. The second story has a rich man who even dresses in rags, denies his son's shoes, had his wife cook some cake only for him, and was so greedy he had it ...