Skip to main content

Singapore Proves That FDIs Aren't There to "Take Jobs Away" from Locals

I'm amazed at the same lies that are still said by similar "thought leaders" such as the members of groups such as Alliance of Concerned Teachers, Anakbayan, Bayan Muna, IBON Foundation, Kabataan Partylist, and League of Filipino Students making their lies about foreign direct investments (FDIs). One of the lies that they made is that foreign investors are there to invade, exploit, and steal away jobs from the locals. We have the Filipino First Policy by Carlos P. Garcia which sadly caused the Philippines to fail. The aim was to make sure that majority of those who own the businesses are Filipinos. However, a big challenging question is if there are enough Filipino businessmen to fill in the supply and demand.

I'm amazed some people quote from portions of the late Lee Kuan Yew's book From Third World to First. Yes, it's often quoted but only if they want to make the current incumbent president, Ferdinand R. Marcos Sr., look bad. I'm still one of the people who don't consider the father, Ferdinand E. Marcos Sr. to be a hero. Yet, we also have it where Singaporean Prime Minister Lee Hsien Loong congratulated Marcos Jr.'s victory. I think Lee Hsien Loong would've still congratulated Maria Leonor Gerona-Robredo would she have won the presidency. Then again, I also don't consider Carlos P. Garcia to be one other. There were quotes about the Marcoses by the great statesman, Lee Kuan Yew. However, the book also talked about the stupid view of development economists of that day. 

Page 58 of From Third World to First also mentioned this thought by Lee Kuan Yew that should be applied to our economic "thought leaders" of today:

The accepted wisdom of development economists at the time was that MNCs were exploiters of cheap land, labor, and raw materials. This "dependency school" of economists argued that MNCs continued the colonial pattern of exploitation that left the developing countries selling raw materials to and buying consumer goods from the advanced countries. MNCs controlled technology and consumer preferences and formed alliances with their host governments to exploit the people and keep them down. Third World leaders believed this theory of neocolonialist exploitation, but Keng Swee and I were not impressed. We had a real-life problem to solve and could not afford to be conscribed by any theory or dogma. Anyway, Singapore had no natural resources for MNCs to exploit. All it had were hard-working people, good basic infrastructure, and a government that was determined to be honest and competent. Our duty was to create a livelihood for 2 million Singaporeans. If MNCs could give our workers employment and teach them technical and engineering skills and management know-how, we should bring in the MNCs.

People can say that it's because Singapore wasn't a country rich in natural resources that it opened the economy. Yet, we can also see how the late great Communist, Nguyen Duy Cong, embraced the Singapore economic model even if Vietnam still remains a Communist country ran under a One-Party State. Vietnam learned from Singapore. Nyugen (also nicknamed Do Muoi) made the Doi Moi program. that's why it's no surprise that Vietnam has defeated the Philippines economically. A sad state that the Philippines is supposedly a democracy yet it practices economic dictatorship in the form of "Filipino First Policy".

Now for a bit of examination. I used to bring up the late John Gokongwei Jr. and these anti-FDI people say, "It's two different topics. Gokongwei is a businessman. Davide Jr. is a lawmaker." Well, that's why I always bring up another former UN diplomat old man in Kishore Mahbubani. That's why I wrote a post where I asked which of these two grandfathers would you listen to regarding economics (read here). I could remember watching the video of The Singapore Economic Model - VRPO Documentary - 2009. It featured Mahbubani who already refuted Davide Jr.'s statement before it can be said. Davide Jr. kept raising his concern about the Philippines becoming a colony of FDIs. Meanwhile, Mahbubani said, "Let's be different!" Mahbubani was also the former dean of the Lee Kuan Yew School of Public Policy at the National University of Singapore. I'm amazed that nine years later, Davide Jr. still hasn't learned from what Mahbubani said.

Singapore today has its businesses developed. Many countries followed its model. Instead, Singapore has provided the jobs that many Filipinos need today. Singaporeans now have more jobs than they had. Besides, it's really becoming more blatant that FDIs only provide jobs for their home countries in other countries is a lie (read here). Singapore has no 60-40 policy regarding share ownership. Yet, the majority of the workforce members in Singapore today are mostly Singaporeans. Once again, that's why the challenge for those anti-FDI naysayers is, "Go tell that to Singapore's government." 

References

Books

"From Third World to First--The Singapore Story: 1965-2000) by Lee Kuan Yew
Harpers Collins Publishers

Videos

"The Singapore economic model - VPRO documentary - 2009"  by VRPO Documentary (September 8, 2018)

Websites

"Ex-chief justice warns PH will be a 'colony' if foreign capital limits are lifted" by Trisha Billones (January 29, 2018) 

Popular posts from this blog

Piracy is Almost Impossible to Defeat Thanks to the Filipino First Policy

Disney Let's face it piracy is hard to combat, right? For Filipinos, it's time to be honest that people have been engaged in piracy in some form. It may be pirated video games, CDs, VCDs, DVDs, etc. There are laws passed against piracy. However, one must ask why piracy is so hard to combat. Piracy bypasses through legalities. It's a common practice to have a pirated version of this and that application, because of the price . Installing MS Office and Windows 11 can be costly. It can cost PHP 7,000.00 for Windows 11 Home and PHP 5,400.00 for MS Office. Back in college, people would do anything to get the MS Office and Windows 11 because they needed it for their projects . It doesn't help that some well-to-do boomer are stingy instead of thrifty. It doesn't help either that some people just can't afford to buy the original software--given their income bracket .  It's easy to raise the Filipino First Policy by saying, "Tangkilikin ang sariling atin!" ...

When the Education Cares TOO MUCH About Grades, Schools Produce Idiots Instead of Intellectuals

During the pandemic, I was left in limbo thinking about my poor performance under K+10. It was something to think about that a classmate of mine who was both a summa cum laude and an honor student, ended up posting on his wall, "Students cheat because the education system cares more about grades instead of learning." The class salutatorian of our batch even commented about the good old days. I always had that feeling of insecurity and envy towards people better than me. But as Warren Edward Buffet would say, "Don't hate successful people. Learn from them instead." One of them is currently a teacher and the other is in Canada. I thought about my insecurities especially when I used to believe I was descended from a fine scholar and my family was a family of scholars.  I remembered the time I was taking MBA and got conned. I was asked, "Is that what MBA taught you?" I got touchy and ended up admitting, eventually, that I was only taking MBA for the presti...

Why I Believe 100% Shares Ownership of Public Utilities Will Help Benefit Filipino Businessmen

Accru Melbourne Typhoon Odette certainly blew another serious blow in the Philippines, didn't it? I could remember the Typhoon Ruping when I was only in Kinder 2. Memories in kindergarten may fade over time but a few don't--such as how some people may mention that they failed kinder for sleeping in classes. The passage of the bill that allows 100% ownership of shares in public utilities has been condemned by certain Filipino organizations such as the League of Filipino Students, Kabataan Partylist, and Bayan Muna. The same old cry of "imperialism" is funny since these groups are using American made social media (such as Facebook and Twitter), they may be ordering meals from Grab which is from Singapore , they are using gadgets made from other countries (such as iPhones which were most likely assembled in China), and other stuff which were obviously not Filipino in origin. A heavy lesson from Odette and other previous disasters The reason why Odette restoration couldn...

My Thoughts on the NOT So Surprising Downfall of "Axie Infinity"

llustration: Daniel Guerrero Fernandez for Bloomberg Businessweek I remembered some time ago when I wrote about Axie Infinity . One article I wrote about why I never bothered to enter the Axie Infinity arena was the poor security . I compared it to a cockfighting game--a game where so few win and so many lose. A previous article I wrote was all about why play-to-earn games are too good to be true . What's not too surprising is the collapse of Axie Infinity . It's pretty much too good to be true. A casual gamer can testify that they buy online passes not to earn but to play . It's like buying a Playstation Plus card to play online for an entire year. You buy games out of the money you earn. You don't earn money out of gaming.  What truly never surprised me was how Axie Infinity crashed. It promised riches but onoy resulted to disaster. I even wrote that there could be an ironic moment somebody says that AXA is a scam while playing Axie Infinity thinking that it's an...

Like Taiwan, the Philippines Can Beat China Economically But It Must Swallow "Filipino First", First!

Taiwan Economic and Cultural Office in the Philippines It's Chinese New Year's Eve tomorrow and this is an essay I felt like writing before the festivities begin. I did write about how Taiwan bested China back then during the time of Mao Zedong . Mao was running his planned utopia via protectionism and it failed miserably . The Great Leap Forward was nothing more than a spectacular failure. Deng Xiaoping had to learn from Singapore in order to bring China forward. I'm afraid that China is going backward at the cost of the Chinese citizens. I don't blame all the Chinese citizens but their government for any tensions. Meanwhile, Taiwan, according to The Heritage Foundation has a score of 80.1% in terms of economic freedom . It's noted as follows: Taiwanā€™s economic freedom score is 80.1, making its economy the 6th freest in the 2022 Index. Taiwan is ranked 3rd among 39 countries in the Asiaā€“Pacific region, and its overall score is above the regional and world averages...

No Amount of INSULTS Would Repeal the Laws of Business and Economics

It's October 2024 and I had no topic to write about a few days ago. Today, I decided to write about how using personal attacks is a common tactic . The use of Ad Hominems or personal attacks is attacking the person instead of the argument. Such people don't care if they contradict themselves--as long as they can insult because they're losers . One of the things I noticed is how I discuss the laws of economics. However, I can get an answer like, "Muh supply and demand! Da conspiracy of supply and demand!" I purposely misspelled the words to show how the person's lack of knowledge and use of mockery. Such persons can repeatedly hurl insults like saying I'm stupid, room temperature IQ, fake IQ, traitor to my fellow Filipino, etc. The list can go on and it's both amusing and irritating to recall every bit of insult I've had. But as advised, I'm told to learn to ignore insults  or laugh at them. An anonymous quote, probably said by Socrates was, ...

Leona's Cakes and Pastries Remains One of My Favorite Bakeshops

Pursuit of Functional Home I would admit I have a sweet tooth that I should put under control. My love for homestyle pastries was with Leona's Cakes and Pastries. My love for this bakery would go for some of my favorite flavors. I remembered going to China last 2007 and stopping by Hong Kong. Hong Kong had its famous Lord Stow's egg custard. It really felt absurd if I would've to fly to Hong Kong just to get it. Fortunately, a bakery in Cebu City was able to fill in that gap and that was Leona's Cake and Pastries. Although I'm not always lucky to get it--I would buy it when I can though it's best eaten on occasion especially when I'm on a weight loss regimen. I was pretty heavy last 2013 and wanted to lose as much weight as possible.  The tarts were the beginning of that love affair with Leona's Cakes and Pastries. What got me more interested in it are the chocolate cake, the banoffee, and my favorite mango chiffon cake . I guess I can't deny mango h...

Why a Wrong Perception of Who is Financially Wealthy is Deadly

I could remember a couple of stuff about a misconception of wealth back when I was in elementary until I was a teenager. I could remember how I envied some of my classmates for their bragging about this and that, their so-called "wealth", and those useless "leaving the uncool kid out" which I felt that I was. It was pretty much a stupid thing to say I'm "poor" because I didn't have the cool video game consoles and the other hand it. Others brag about their cars such as having a Pajero or a Mercedes Benz. Others even brag about their thick wallets while I hardly had a thick wallet because my parents were thrifty. If I overspent--I had to deal with having less money. I had to learn how to save as a teenager up to my college days because of limited allowances from thrifty parents. I could think of these reasons vs. rebuttals that I've learned in life when I showed my jealousy: I used to say that somebody was richer because his or her car was luxur...

The Filipino First Policy Caused the Philippines to Succeed!

High School Philippine History Movement Yes, you read it right! I found a hidden gem that I should've read years ago! It's the book Nationalist Economics by the late Alejandro Lichauco, who is part of the magnificent IBON Foundation. It's a shame I refused to read it. I should've read Lichauco's book instead of the late Lee Kuan Yew's book From Third World to First . What a shame that I didn't look into the details that LKY was a dictator, that Flor Contemplacion was indeed innocent, and that Singapore is a state comparable to Nazi Germany. As I bought my copy of Nationalist Economics from the Trust Me Bro School of Economics--I'm now convinced that the Filipino First Policy caused us to succeed! LKY ruled Singapore for 31 years, meaning it's a frightening thing indeed! Six years is the magic number ot establish a benevolent rule!  Who should we all listen to? Should we listen to foreigners or should we listen to our fellow Filipino? We must think st...

Trying to Understand More About the Philippine Equity Smart Index Fund

There was a time when I had some excess savings. I was worried my money was getting idle . Sure, savings is king but letting it sit idle in a savings account can be a bad thing. Sure, I'm having my AXA Chinese Tycoon Fund for some time and I haven't withdrawn a single cent from it. I decided to use GCash and found out how it's actually convenient. With GCash, there's also GInvest. One of GInvest's greatest products for me to indirectly get into stocks would be the Philippine Equity Smart Index Fund. I placed a few pesos at first because of the low rate. However, I decided to aim to invest at least PHP 1,000.00 per month (or more during a dip but not too much either) or reach a certain target before the year ends. Of course, I've got to curb my impulsive behavior by choosing not to invest too much and not have savings. The ATRAM Philippine Equity Smart Index Fund combines both active and passive investment. Some people prefer purely active or purely passive. It...