Skip to main content

The Philippines 60-40 Equity Scheme Doesn't Prohibit FDIs But It's Still VERY DISCOURAGING for International Business


First and foremost, I'd like to tell people that I don't believe that the Marcos Years were the "golden years". I still agree with economist Cielo Magno that land ownership isn't a factor, since some countries without equity restrictions, don't allow foreigners to buy land. In contrast, inflation and the like were rampant during that time. However, we need to realize that any gains after EDSA 1986 weren't realized. As I was looking at Facebook, a page called Punch the Lies by Atty. Mike Navallo stated this: 
FACT: The 1987 Constitution does not prohibit entry of global investors into PH. What it regulates is foreign investment in areas deemed critical such as public utilities; exploration, devt and use of natural resources; and certain investments as determined by Congress. (Art XII) 
Public utilities (water, electricity, petroleum distribution, seaports, PUVs) are considered vital to socio-economic devt that's why they're subject to foreign ownership limits. 
There's also a question on national security. Remember concerns over Chinese involvement in NGCP? 
The Public Services Act was amended in 2022 excluding from the definition of "public utility" services such as telecomms and transportation, therefore allowing foreign ownership. 
It would be easy to look down on me because I'm not a lawyer. However, in this digital age, I don't need to be a lawyer to understand the basics. I'd like to address the elephant in the room here. However, I'd like to address the common sense issue of public services. It's said by Punch the Lies that the reason why they're subject to foreign ownership limits is because they're vital to socio-economic development. However, what can we do if the costs of water, electricity, petroleum distribution, seaports, and PUVs are too expensive due to the simple rule of supply and demand?

Earlier, I wrote an article about the stupidity of having equity restrictions--in the name of security. Of course, I expect these people to keep quoting mostly Filipino economists and lawyers. Their favorite people are the likes of Atty. Hilario G. Davide Jr., Atty. Christian Monsod, and Professor Solita "Winnie" Collas-Monsod, to name a few. They also love to quote from the IBON Foundation. I find the idea of subjecting businesses to 60-40 in the name of security, to be utterly stupid. It's not like as if certain laws such as taxation laws, labor laws, data privacy act, etc. don't provide necessary restrictions.

The 60-40 arrangement is nothing more than overpriced rent (read here). Who in their right mind would want to rent a space if they have to give 60% ownership to the lessor? Let's say I prepare a shopping mall. However, I require all my tenants to give me 60% of their ownership, which in turn entitles me to 60% of their profits. Even worse, I'd be stingy to give them a good place. It's definitely not paying for the value. In turn, even when I don't prohibit tenants from entering, my conditions would still discourage them from entering.

If people are wondering why Communist Vietnam has been more viable for business--please check their policies on foreign investment. In fact, the Vietnam Briefing reveals that most industries (except a few) allow up to 100% foreign ownership of shares. Vietnam doesn't allow land ownership. Please stop confusing land ownership with share ownership! The Vietnam Embassy states that for certain sectors, the ownership limit granted to investors is 70%, not 40%. A 30% difference really makes a difference in why more go to Vietnam. Please, Vietnam isn't that protectionist paradise as some fools want to paint it out to be. It may still be under the Communist Party of Vietnam but Doi Moi changed its economic policy significantly (read here).

Image by Sabrina Jiang © Investopedia 2020

I'm afraid most people who support the 60-40 policy confuse profits with revenues (read here). If they're worried about FDIs and will run away with their profits, then listen. FDIs get rich based on their net income after taxes (read here). Please, a sample income statement will show you that net income is what's left after all expenses have been paid. For some, it's just some "capitalist conspiracy used as an excuse". However, basic economics is no "capitalist conspiracy". Common sense will tell you that supply and demand drive the market price. Common sense will tell you that businesses don't just earn, they must also spend. FDIs will still be required to pay all types of taxes required. These taxes can be the value tax, income tax, and withholding taxes. Just because they own 100% of their business, doesn't mean they don't pay taxes. 

To explain it in simple terms--an FDI may get a monthly revenue of PHP 277,700.00. However, all the expenses paid such as salaries, utility bills, depreciation, interest due to debt, etc. will be deducted from the revenues. Eventually, the taxable amount is PHP 111,000.00. Now, let's say that the taxes would be subjected to 12% VAT. The remaining net income after tax (for the month) would be PHP 97,680.00. That means the corporate income for the month is only 35% of their revenues for the month. An increase in sales doesn't always translate to an increase in income. Would the company really want to part 60% of what's left after all expenses, with a Filipino oligarch? 
Labels:

Popular posts from this blog

Pinoy Pride Economics Helps in Drug Mule Recruitment

Al Jazeera Who can remember the execution of three drug mules in China on March 30, 2011 ? These were three separate cases where the three convicts were  Sally Villanueva , Ramon Credo (who was cremated before his remains were brought home, and Elizabeth Batain (whose face was never shown). Sally had an episode in the GMA-7 TV show Magpakailanman,  where her husband was personally interviewed by Mel Tiangco. We never got Sally on the big screen. The husband's side of the story said that his wife was guilty of a frame-up, while Mel herself said, "If the offer is too good to be true, don't take it, or you could end up in the same pickle." Take note that I'm just paraphrasing Mel's words, not saying the words she said.  Reviewing the three drug mules who got arrested, based only on what's available for public viewing on the Internet If we read through the circumstances , this is how they were arrested, proving they weren't a trio: China has brushed aside...
Read more

It's More Fun In The Philippines Thanks to the Filipino First Policy

I guess it can be called a day, right? This April 1, 2023 , I'm finally calling it quits with fighting for economic liberalization! Yes, that's right! All the advocacy for economic liberalization is just garbage. Why did I even spend so much time writing this blog only to find out that I've been duped? I hereby renounce everything I wrote here. I finally saw how brilliant the Filipino First Policy is. Man, what have I done? How much damage have I caused in advocating for economic liberalization?  The greatest president we ever had was... High School Philippine History Movement It's time to listen to the economic genius known as the late Carlos P. Garcia. Yes, he has to be one of the greatest presidents that ever existed.  I took this note from the Bohol Provincial Library and found this about CPG's Filipino First Policy ; CPG adopted the “Filipino First” Policy to promote greater Filipino participation in business, and to put the Filipinos in control of the economy...
Read more

New Study Confirms Oil Degulation Law is Bad, Oil Nationalization is Better

Yes, you found that right. Did you know that the Filipino First Policy caused the Philippines to succeed and Carlos P. Garcia was the best president ever? Today, because of the Iranian War crisis, we need to talk about a new important discovery. What I realized is that the oil deregulation policy is bad . Do you want the oil prices to fall under control? Then read this new blog to find out.  A new audit was revealed in the world's greatest economic forum. The Trust Me Bro School of Economics invited the trustworthy IBON Foundation to speak at Intrigador Financials . I was so wrong not to notice the genius behind the likes of Makabayan Bloc.  What have I done compared to the youths  of Kabataan Partylist ? I even discovered that  the IBON Foundation is the most credible economic think tank . As I realized that  Filipinos should only listen to Filipino economists ,  I have found that there are literally  tons of studies  from the famous Trust Me Br...
Read more

Yes, the Philippines Can Self-Industrialize Because Filipinos Are the Most Powerful Race in the World (NO JOKE)

Yes, you got that right! This meme is a fact that Filipinos are the most powerful race in the world. That has been proven by the Trust Me Bro Factcheckers of the Philippines. It's the case of Filipino Exceptionalism. One can read on Facebook something like, "How many times do I have to tell you that the Philippines isn't Vietnam/Singapore/China/Taiwan/Japan, etc.?" Ever read that? If you haven't then you must be exceptionally stupid. That's why the Philippines should never learn from other countries, especially from Singapore. Why are you always listening to foreigners? Why listen to the advice of a stinky Indian when you can have the advice of the best constitutionalist in the world, Atty. Hilario G. Davide Jr.? You say that nations of the world go to Kishore Mabhubani in Singapore instead. Forget them because the Philippines is so unique that it can do everything on its own. It was proven by the greatest president that the Philippines always had, namely Carl...
Read more

The Filipino First Policy Caused the Philippines to Succeed!

High School Philippine History Movement Yes, you read it right! I found a hidden gem that I should've read years ago! It's the book Nationalist Economics by the late Alejandro Lichauco, who is part of the magnificent IBON Foundation. It's a shame I refused to read it. I should've read Lichauco's book instead of the late Lee Kuan Yew's book From Third World to First . What a shame that I didn't look into the details that LKY was a dictator, that Flor Contemplacion was indeed innocent, and that Singapore is a state comparable to Nazi Germany. As I bought my copy of Nationalist Economics from the Trust Me Bro School of Economics--I'm now convinced that the Filipino First Policy caused us to succeed! LKY ruled Singapore for 31 years, meaning it's a frightening thing indeed! Six years is the magic number ot establish a benevolent rule!  Who should we all listen to? Should we listen to foreigners or should we listen to our fellow Filipino? We must think st...
Read more